Koller W C, Vetere-Overfield B
Department of Neurology, University of Kansas Medical Center, Kansas City 66103.
Neurology. 1989 Dec;39(12):1587-8. doi: 10.1212/wnl.39.12.1587.
We studied the acute and chronic effects of propranolol and primidone in essential tremor by administering long-acting propranolol (80 to 160 mg/d) and primidone (50 to 250 mg/d) to 50 patients. We evaluated patients at 1, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months after treatment and assessed tremor by subjective rating by patients, clinical scoring, and thermographic (accelerometer) recordings. Acute adverse reactions occurred in 8% with propranolol and 32% with primidone. Propranolol was without therapeutic effect in 30%, and 32% had no benefit from primidone. Significant chronic side effects occurred in 17% taking propranolol and in 0% with primidone. Tolerance to drug effect occurred with chronic treatment in 12.5% of patients with propranolol and 13.0% with primidone. We conclude that propranolol and primidone are effective long-term treatment for some patients with essential tremor. Acute adverse reactions with primidone and side effects with chronic use of propranolol hamper therapy.
我们对50例特发性震颤患者给予长效普萘洛尔(80至160毫克/天)和扑米酮(50至250毫克/天),研究了普萘洛尔和扑米酮对特发性震颤的急性和慢性影响。我们在治疗后1、3、6、9和12个月对患者进行评估,并通过患者主观评分、临床评分和热成像(加速度计)记录来评估震颤情况。使用普萘洛尔的患者中有8%出现急性不良反应,使用扑米酮的患者中有32%出现急性不良反应。30%的患者使用普萘洛尔无治疗效果,32%的患者使用扑米酮无获益。服用普萘洛尔的患者中有17%出现显著的慢性副作用,而服用扑米酮的患者中这一比例为0%。12.5%使用普萘洛尔的患者和13.0%使用扑米酮的患者在长期治疗后出现药物效应耐受性。我们得出结论,普萘洛尔和扑米酮对一些特发性震颤患者是有效的长期治疗药物。扑米酮的急性不良反应和普萘洛尔长期使用的副作用妨碍了治疗。