Issah Kofi, Nartey Kennedy, Amoah Richard, Bachan Emmanuel George, Aleeba Jacob, Yeetey Enuamah, Letsa Timothy
Ghana Health Service, Regional Health Directorate, P.O. Box 145, Sunyani, Brong Ahafo Region Ghana.
Kintampo Health Centre, Ghana Health Service, Kintampo, Brong Ahafo Region Ghana.
Infect Dis Poverty. 2015 Apr 10;4:17. doi: 10.1186/s40249-015-0051-3. eCollection 2015.
This study assessed the quality, core and support functions of the integrated disease surveillance and response (IDSR) system relating to 18 suspected cases of Ebola virus disease (EVD) in the Brong Ahafo Region, Ghana.
Data was collected on selected indicators of the surveillance system relating to 18 suspected cases of EVD, from epidemiological week 19 to 45 of 2014. We conducted in-depth interviews with seven medical directors and two district directors of health services, and also reviewed documentation on the implementation of the core, support and quality functions of the IDSR system. We also monitored news in the media and rumours about EVD within the community as well as in health facility surveillance registers.
The study identified gaps in the implementation of IDSR relating to 18 suspected cases of EVD. Health staff heavily relied on haemorrhage as the only symptom for detection of suspected EVD cases. Twelve blood samples and a swab of secretions from the mouth of the thirteenth patient (who died) tested negative for EVD using PCR assay in laboratory confirmation. The blood samples of three patients were discarded, as they did not fit the case definition for suspected cases, whilst two refused for their blood samples to be taken. The community-based surveillance (CBS) system has not been given a prominent role in EVD surveillance and response, as demonstrated by CBS volunteers and health staff not receiving any training in these processes. There was intense public interest in EVD in August and September 2014. That interest has since waned for reasons that have to be formally ascertained. Unfounded fear of and anxiety about EVD still remain challenges due to a lack of in-depth knowledge about the disease in Ghana.
Ghana has been one of the pioneers in the implementation of IDSR in Africa. Despite this, gaps have been identified in the implementation of IDSR relating to EVD in the Brong Ahafo Region. To address these gaps, the CBS system has to actively partner with health facility surveillance to achieve effective IDSR in the region.
本研究评估了加纳布朗阿哈福地区综合疾病监测与应对(IDSR)系统针对18例埃博拉病毒病(EVD)疑似病例的质量、核心及支持功能。
收集了2014年第19至45流行病学周期间与18例EVD疑似病例相关的监测系统选定指标的数据。我们对7名医务主任和2名地区卫生服务主任进行了深入访谈,还查阅了关于IDSR系统核心、支持及质量功能实施情况的文件。我们还监测了媒体上有关EVD的新闻以及社区内和医疗机构监测登记册中的谣言。
该研究发现了IDSR系统在18例EVD疑似病例实施方面的差距。卫生工作人员严重依赖出血作为检测EVD疑似病例的唯一症状。12份血液样本以及第13例患者(已死亡)口腔分泌物拭子经实验室PCR检测,EVD呈阴性。3例患者的血液样本因不符合疑似病例的病例定义而被丢弃,同时有2例拒绝采集血液样本。基于社区的监测(CBS)系统在EVD监测与应对中未发挥突出作用,CBS志愿者和卫生工作人员未接受过这些流程的培训即体现了这一点。2014年8月和9月公众对EVD兴趣浓厚。此后兴趣有所下降,原因有待正式查明。由于加纳对该疾病缺乏深入了解,对EVD毫无根据的恐惧和焦虑仍然是挑战。
加纳是非洲实施IDSR的先驱之一。尽管如此,布朗阿哈福地区在EVD相关的IDSR实施方面仍存在差距。为弥补这些差距,CBS系统必须与医疗机构监测积极合作,以在该地区实现有效的IDSR。