Buffel Veerle, van de Straat Vera, Bracke Piet
Department of Sociology, Health and Demographic Research group [HeDeRa], Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Int J Equity Health. 2015 Mar 11;14:29. doi: 10.1186/s12939-015-0153-3.
Framed within the recent economic crisis, in this study we investigate the medical mental health care use of the unemployed compared with that of the employed in Europe, and whether the relationship between employment status and mental health care use varies across macro-economic conditions. We examine whether the macro-economic context and changes therein are related to mental health care use, via their impact on mental health, or more directly, irrespective of mental health.
We use data from three waves of the Eurobarometer (2002, 2005/2006, and 2010), which has a repeated cross-sectional and cross-national design. Linear and logistic multilevel regression analyses are performed with mental health, contacting a general practitioner, and contacting a psychiatrist for mental health problems as dependent variables. The multilevel design has three levels (the individual, the period-country, and the country), which allows us to estimate both longitudinal and cross-sectional macro-effects. The macro-economic context and changes therein are assessed using national unemployment rates and growth rates in Gross Domestic Product (GDP).
The mean unemployment rate is negatively related to mental health, although for women, this effect only applies to the employed. Among women, no relationship is found between changes in the macro-economic context and mental health. The unemployment rate, and changes in both the unemployment rate and the real GDP growth rate, are associated with men's care use, regardless of their mental health, whereas this does not hold for women. In countries with an increase in the unemployment rate, both unemployed and employed men tend to medicalize their problems more by contacting a general practitioner, irrespective of their mental health, while the likelihood of contacting a psychiatrist is lower among employed men.
Our findings stress the importance of taking the macro-economic context and changes therein into account when studying the mental health care use of unemployed people compared with the employed, in particular among men. Moreover, it is important to make the distinction between primary and specialized medical care use, as the impact of macro-economic conditions is dependent on the type of care, which also applies when controlling for mental health.
在近期经济危机的背景下,本研究调查了欧洲失业者与就业者的医疗心理健康服务使用情况,以及就业状况与心理健康服务使用之间的关系是否因宏观经济状况而异。我们研究宏观经济背景及其变化是否通过对心理健康的影响,或更直接地,无论心理健康状况如何,与心理健康服务使用相关。
我们使用了欧洲晴雨表三轮调查(2002年、2005/2006年和2010年)的数据,该调查采用重复横截面和跨国设计。以心理健康、因心理健康问题联系全科医生以及联系精神科医生作为因变量,进行线性和逻辑多水平回归分析。多水平设计有三个层次(个体、时期 - 国家和国家),这使我们能够估计纵向和横截面的宏观效应。使用国家失业率和国内生产总值(GDP)增长率评估宏观经济背景及其变化。
平均失业率与心理健康呈负相关,不过对于女性而言,这种影响仅适用于就业者。在女性中,未发现宏观经济背景变化与心理健康之间存在关联。失业率以及失业率和实际GDP增长率的变化,与男性的医疗服务使用相关,无论其心理健康状况如何,而女性则不然。在失业率上升的国家,无论心理健康状况如何,失业和就业的男性都更倾向于通过联系全科医生将他们的问题医学化,而就业男性联系精神科医生的可能性较低。
我们的研究结果强调,在研究失业者与就业者的心理健康服务使用情况时,尤其是在男性中,考虑宏观经济背景及其变化的重要性。此外,区分初级医疗服务和专科医疗服务的使用很重要,因为宏观经济状况的影响取决于医疗服务类型,在控制心理健康状况时也是如此。