Camfield Carol, Camfield Peter
Department of Pediatrics, Dalhousie University and IWK Health Centre, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Department of Pediatrics, Dalhousie University and IWK Health Centre, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Seizure. 2015 Apr;27:80-3. doi: 10.1016/j.seizure.2015.02.031. Epub 2015 Mar 6.
Document the frequency, types and risk factors for injuries caused by seizures for people with childhood onset epilepsy.
We contacted patients with all types of epilepsy except childhood absence from the Nova Scotia Childhood Epilepsy population-based cohort. Seizure onset was between 1977 and 1985. Patients and parents were asked about serious injuries resulting from a seizure, defined as severe enough for an urgent physician or dentist visit.
Of 595 eligible patients, we contacted 472 (79%). During an average follow up of 23.9 ± 8 years, 52 (11%) experienced ≥1 serious injury for a total of 81 injuries. Of all injuries, 24 (30%) were lacerations requiring sutures, 15 (19%) fractures, 11 (14%) broken teeth, 8 (10%) concussions, 4 (5%) burns, and 20 (25%) other. "Other" included 1 fatal drowning, 2 near-drownings, 3 shoulder dislocations and 1 severe eye injury. Four injuries occurred with the first seizure; all others after a long gap from seizure onset (range 1.5-30 years). Injuries occurred in all epilepsy syndromes, most commonly with symptomatic generalized epilepsy (17% vs. 11% p = 0.03) and intractable epilepsy (28% vs. 8% p<0.0001). Most injuries occurred during normal daily activities and were judged not to be easily preventable.
During ∼24 years of follow up 1 out of 10 patients with childhood onset epilepsy had a serious injury as the result of a seizure. Most injuries occurred years after the initial diagnosis and were more common when seizures were more frequent. The only practical solution to injury prevention is better seizure control.
记录儿童期起病癫痫患者癫痫发作所致损伤的频率、类型及危险因素。
我们联系了新斯科舍省儿童癫痫人群队列中除儿童失神癫痫外的所有类型癫痫患者。癫痫发作起始时间为1977年至1985年。询问患者及其父母有关癫痫发作导致的严重损伤情况,严重损伤定义为严重到足以促使患者紧急就医或看牙医。
在595名符合条件的患者中,我们联系到了472名(79%)。在平均23.9±8年的随访期间,52名(11%)患者经历了≥1次严重损伤,共计81次损伤。在所有损伤中,24次(30%)为需要缝合的撕裂伤,15次(19%)为骨折,11次(14%)为牙齿折断,8次(10%)为脑震荡,4次(5%)为烧伤,20次(25%)为其他损伤。“其他”损伤包括1例致命溺水、2例近乎溺水、3例肩关节脱位和1例严重眼外伤。4次损伤发生在首次癫痫发作时;其余所有损伤均在癫痫发作起始后很长一段时间(范围为1.5 - 30年)出现。所有癫痫综合征均有损伤发生,最常见于症状性全身性癫痫(17%对11%,p = 0.03)和难治性癫痫(28%对8%,p<0.0001)。大多数损伤发生在日常正常活动期间,且被判定不易预防。
在约24年的随访期间,10名儿童期起病癫痫患者中有1名因癫痫发作导致严重损伤。大多数损伤发生在初始诊断多年后,且癫痫发作较频繁时更常见。预防损伤的唯一实际解决办法是更好地控制癫痫发作。