Brown Craig, Ross Sarah, Cleland Jennifer, Walsh Kieran
a University of Aberdeen , UK.
b BMJ Learning , UK.
Med Teach. 2015 Jul;37(7):653-659. doi: 10.3109/0142159X.2015.1033389. Epub 2015 Apr 29.
The widely used Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) is undoubtedly expensive. Cost-effectiveness is one of the components of the assessment utility index defining its usefulness. Our current financial climate demands increased transparency in the costs associated with medical education and it is now vital to ascertain how much is spent on assessments, such as the OSCE, and in particular costs associated with the different types of stations within the OSCE.
A retrospective case-study approach was used to identify all costs associated with the development, production, administration and post-examination phases of the 2013 final year MBChB OSCE at the University of Aberdeen, Scotland. This 15 station OSCE was held over 2 days for 185 students.
This OSCE cost £65,328 to run. Costs per station ranged from £3108 (prescribing) to £6577 (eye examination). The cost per student was £355.
The costs of a "high stakes" OSCE are sobering. The bulk of costs identified are not modifiable in light of what is currently known about the metrics of OSCE utility, particularly reliability and validity.
Providers, and funders, of medical education must be prepared to assign significant resource to OSCE assessment and centres should be encouraged to calculate precise costs associated with assessment to inform resource allocation decisions.
广泛使用的客观结构化临床考试(OSCE)无疑成本高昂。成本效益是定义其效用的评估效用指数的组成部分之一。我们当前的财务状况要求提高医学教育相关成本的透明度,现在至关重要的是确定在诸如OSCE等评估上花费了多少,特别是与OSCE内不同类型考站相关的成本。
采用回顾性案例研究方法,确定与2013年苏格兰阿伯丁大学医学学士最后一年OSCE的开发、制作、管理和考试后阶段相关的所有成本。这个包含15个考站的OSCE为期2天,共有185名学生参加。
此次OSCE的运行成本为65,328英镑。每个考站的成本从3108英镑(开处方)到6577英镑(眼科检查)不等。每名学生的成本为355英镑。
“高风险”OSCE的成本令人警醒。根据目前已知的OSCE效用指标,特别是可靠性和有效性,已确定的大部分成本无法更改。
医学教育的提供者和资助者必须准备好为OSCE评估分配大量资源,并且应鼓励各中心计算与评估相关的精确成本,以便为资源分配决策提供依据。