Kolkman Paul, Soliman Mohsin, Kolkman Marcy, Stack Apollo, Rao T Subramanyeshwar, Mukta Srinivasulu, Schmid Kendra, Thompson Jon, Are Chandrakanth
Division of General Surgery, University of Nebraska Medical Center, 983280 Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, NE USA.
College of Nursing, University of Nebraska Medical Center, 985330 Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, NE USA.
Indian J Surg Oncol. 2015 Mar;6(1):36-40. doi: 10.1007/s13193-015-0389-9. Epub 2015 Mar 18.
This study compared the operative case log experience between rotations during General Surgery residency in the United States and an international rotation in India. A resident from the General Surgery residency program at University of Nebraska Medical Center participated in an international rotation in Surgical Oncology at Mehdi Nawaz Jung Institute of Oncology in Hyderabad, India for 3 months in 2009. The operative case log of this resident (INT) was compared to those of another resident (US) on a rotation in surgical oncology at the parent institution during the same time period. Both institutions were tertiary care centers. We noted that the INT resident performed a greater number of cases (132) when compared to the US resident (61). The INT resident also performed cases in a wider variety of disease categories such as: head and neck (26 %), gynecology (19 %), breast (14 %) and urology (4 %). In contrast, abdominal cases accounted for 68 % of the cases performed by the US resident with fewer cases in the other categories. The INT resident performed 98 % of the cases by the open approach, whereas the US resident performed only 81 % of cases by the open approach, with the remaining 19 % of cases performed by the laparoscopic approach. The results demonstrate that the INT resident performed a greater number of operative cases when compared to a resident (US) at the parent institution, and performed cases in more diverse disease categories with an emphasis on the open operative approach.
本研究比较了美国普通外科住院医师培训期间不同轮转阶段与印度国际轮转期间的手术病例记录经验。2009年,内布拉斯加大学医学中心普通外科住院医师培训项目的一名住院医师在印度海得拉巴的梅赫迪·纳瓦兹·荣肿瘤研究所参加了为期3个月的外科肿瘤学国际轮转。将该住院医师(INT)的手术病例记录与同期在母机构进行外科肿瘤学轮转的另一名住院医师(US)的记录进行比较。两家机构均为三级医疗中心。我们注意到,与US住院医师(61例)相比,INT住院医师实施的病例数更多(132例)。INT住院医师还处理了更广泛的疾病类别,如:头颈(26%)、妇科(19%)、乳腺(14%)和泌尿外科(4%)。相比之下,腹部病例占US住院医师所做手术的68%,其他类别病例较少。INT住院医师98%的病例采用开放手术方式,而US住院医师仅81%的病例采用开放手术方式,其余19%的病例采用腹腔镜手术方式。结果表明,与母机构的住院医师(US)相比,INT住院医师实施的手术病例更多,且处理的疾病类别更多样化,更侧重于开放手术方式。