Strange Charlie, Monk Richard, Schwarz Laura, Walker Deirdre, Kumbhare Suchit, Bieko Tatsiana
Division of Pulmonary, Critical Care, Allergy and Sleep Medicine, Medical University of South Carolina , Charleston, South Carolina , USA.
COPD. 2015 May;12 Suppl 1:42-5. doi: 10.3109/15412555.2015.1021914.
The Alpha-1 Foundation Research Registry has a long history of facilitating research studies in the United States. The current contact registry is used to invite participants to research studies. However, the next generation of individuals diagnosed with alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency may look quite different from historical cohorts. This paper uses data from the Alpha Coded Testing (ACT) study, a home genetic testing program in which deficient individuals are invited to participate in the Registry, to demonstrate the impact that selection bias can introduce into registry data. Environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) exposure is rapidly declining in the United States. We queried whether consecutive non-smokers with or without childhood ETS in ACT (N = 801) had been diagnosed with COPD more often if deficiency genes were defined in subsequent testing. The prevalence of COPD was not different between cohorts with or without ETS exposure between normal (PiMM and PiMS), moderately deficient (PiMZ, PiMNull, and PiSS), and severely deficient (PiSZ, PiZZ, PiSNull, and PiZNull) genotypes. Surprisingly, age adjusted COPD Severity Scores in this cohort were higher for individuals with normal genotypes compared to moderately (P<0.001) and severely (P = 0.04) deficient genotypes. Ascertainment bias of testing within families (which yields the highest incidence of deficiency genotypes) also finds many family members without symptoms, even over the age of 40. We conclude that the future utility of registries will depend on accurate determination of testing mechanics. Larger database initiatives using the COPD Patient Powered Research Network are described.
α-1基金会研究注册库在美国推动研究方面有着悠久的历史。当前的联系注册库用于邀请参与者参与研究。然而,下一代被诊断为α-1抗胰蛋白酶缺乏症的个体可能与历史队列有很大不同。本文使用来自α编码检测(ACT)研究的数据,这是一个家庭基因检测项目,其中缺陷个体被邀请加入注册库,以证明选择偏倚可能引入注册库数据的影响。在美国,环境烟草烟雾(ETS)暴露正在迅速下降。我们询问在ACT研究中(N = 801),如果在后续检测中定义了缺陷基因,连续的非吸烟者(无论有无儿童期ETS暴露)被诊断为慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)的频率是否更高。在正常(PiMM和PiMS)、中度缺陷(PiMZ、PiMNull和PiSS)以及严重缺陷(PiSZ、PiZZ、PiSNull和PiZNull)基因型中,有或没有ETS暴露的队列之间COPD的患病率没有差异。令人惊讶的是,与中度(P<0.001)和严重(P = 0.04)缺陷基因型相比,该队列中正常基因型个体的年龄调整COPD严重程度评分更高。家庭内部检测的确诊偏倚(这导致缺陷基因型的发病率最高)也发现许多家庭成员没有症状,甚至超过40岁。我们得出结论,注册库未来的效用将取决于检测机制的准确确定。本文还描述了使用COPD患者驱动研究网络的更大数据库计划。