From the Institute of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology (S.W., F.M., M.v.W., H.A., P.S.) and Institute of Pathology (V.T., L.B., H.M.), University Hospital Zurich, Raemistrasse 100, 8091 Zurich, Switzerland; Department of Forensic Medicine and Radiology, Institute of Forensic Medicine, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland (S.W., S.B., M.T., P.S.); Swiss Light Source, Paul Scherrer Institute, Villigen, Switzerland (S.P., P.M., M.S.); and Institute for Biomedical Engineering, University and ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland (S.P., M.S.).
Radiology. 2015 Oct;277(1):64-72. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2015141614. Epub 2015 May 5.
To investigate the accuracy of x-ray grating interferometry phase-contrast (PC) imaging for the characterization of human coronary artery plaque.
PC and conventional absorption computed tomographic (CT) imaging was performed ex vivo in this institutional review board-approved study in 40 human coronary artery segments by using a synchrotron radiation source. Qualitative analyses and calculations of image quality (McNemar test), plaque components (McNemar test), and plaque classification (Cohen κ test) according to the American Heart Association classification were performed in 38 plaques detected at histopathologic examination (reference standard). Quantitative measurements of plaque components (ie, collagen, lipids, smooth muscle, and calcifications) were compared among PC and absorption images by using analysis of variance for repeated measures with post hoc Bonferroni correction.
Image quality was superior in PC (median image score, 1) in all cases (100%) compared with absorption imaging (median image score, 3) (P < .001). Plaque components were detected by means of PC without significant differences (seven of seven calcifications, 22 of 22 plaques with collagen and smooth muscle cells, P > .99; 29 of 29 plaques with lipids, P = .10) with histopathologic findings, whereas absorption imaging was used to detect calcifications (seven of seven, P > .99) without statistical differences only (nine of 29 plaques with lipids, 0 of 22 plaques with collagen and smooth muscle cells, P < .001). Accuracy for plaque stage assessment with PC (early vs advanced) was 100%, and characterization was correct in 33 of 38 plaques (87%), while conventional absorption imaging allowed correct characterization of seven plaques only (18%, P < .001). PC CT numbers were significantly different (P < .05) for all plaque components (mean for calcifications, 1236 HU ± 69; collagen, 78 HU ± 24; lipids, -18 HU ± 23; and smooth muscle cells, 34 HU ± 12), whereas absorption images showed significant differences (P < .001) between calcifications (1336 HU ± 241) and other plaque components, but not for collagen (22 HU ± 13), lipids (-15 HU ± 14), and smooth muscle (13 HU ± 9) (P > .99).
PC imaging allows accurate characterization of human coronary artery plaques and quantitative assessment of plaque components, thereby outperforming absorption imaging.
研究 X 射线光栅干涉相位对比(PC)成像在人冠状动脉斑块特征描述中的准确性。
本研究经机构审查委员会批准,在 40 个人体冠状动脉节段中,使用同步辐射源进行了 PC 和常规吸收计算机断层扫描(CT)成像。对 38 个在组织病理学检查中发现的斑块(参考标准)进行了 3 种分析:定性分析和图像质量(McNemar 检验)、斑块成分(McNemar 检验)、根据美国心脏协会分类的斑块分类(Cohen κ 检验)。采用重复测量方差分析比较 PC 和吸收图像中斑块成分(即胶原、脂质、平滑肌和钙化)的定量测量,并用事后 Bonferroni 校正进行比较。
与吸收成像(中位数图像评分 3)相比,PC 在所有病例中(100%)的图像质量均更优(中位数图像评分 1)(P <.001)。PC 可无显著差异地检测到所有 7 个钙化、22 个有胶原和平滑肌细胞的斑块(22 个,P >.99)、29 个有脂质的斑块(P =.10),而吸收成像仅用于检测钙化(7 个,P >.99),但差异无统计学意义(9 个有脂质的斑块、0 个有胶原和平滑肌细胞的斑块,P <.001)。PC 对斑块分期评估(早期与晚期)的准确率为 100%,38 个斑块中有 33 个(87%)的特征描述正确,而常规吸收成像仅能正确描述 7 个斑块(18%,P <.001)。PC CT 数在所有斑块成分之间均有显著差异(P <.05)(钙化的平均值为 1236 HU ± 69;胶原为 78 HU ± 24;脂质为 -18 HU ± 23;平滑肌细胞为 34 HU ± 12),而吸收图像在钙化(1336 HU ± 241)与其他斑块成分之间有显著差异(P <.001),但在胶原(22 HU ± 13)、脂质(-15 HU ± 14)和平滑肌(13 HU ± 9)之间无显著差异(P >.99)。
PC 成像可准确描述人冠状动脉斑块,并定量评估斑块成分,优于吸收成像。