Magota S
Nihon Igaku Hoshasen Gakkai Zasshi. 1989 Aug 25;49(8):1038-46.
Conventional Radiography, Fuji Computed Radiography (FCR) hardcopy and CRT images were evaluated about the detectability of pulmonary nodule using the chest phantom. Conventional and digitized chest radiographs (FCR) were used, including 45 normal cases and 45 abnormal cases with a variety pulmonary nodule. Observer performance tests were conducted to compare the effects on diagnostic accuracy of Conventional Radiography, FCR hardcopy and CRT images, and diagnostic accuracy was determined with receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis. ROC study was performed in which six radiologists were asked to locate nodule on three modalities. Two CRT monitors were used to observed CRT images. The left side CRT monitor was divided into two parts and displayed two images which were done as same image processing as FCR hardcopy. The right side CRT monitor was divided into four parts and displayed four images as a subsidiary diagnosis. The upper two images were displayed to diagnose the nodule of cardiac and diaphragmatic area, and lower two images were displayed to diagnose the nodule of the lung field. The results were summarized as follows: 1) CRT images were superior in sensitivity (78.5%) to the others, and FCR hardcopys were superior in specificity (95.9%). 2) About the accuracy of 5 and 8 mm in diameter nodule detection, there was no significant difference among three modalities. 3) Diagnostic accuracy of 3 mm in diameter nodule detection was significantly greater with digitized radiographs (FCR 44.4%, CRT images 54.4%) than with conventional radiograph (17.7%).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
使用胸部模型,对传统放射成像、富士计算机放射成像(FCR)硬拷贝和阴极射线管(CRT)图像的肺结节可检测性进行了评估。使用了传统的和数字化的胸部X光片(FCR),包括45例正常病例和45例有各种肺结节的异常病例。进行了观察者性能测试,以比较传统放射成像、FCR硬拷贝和CRT图像对诊断准确性的影响,并通过接受者操作特征(ROC)分析确定诊断准确性。进行了ROC研究,其中要求六位放射科医生在三种模式下定位结节。使用两台CRT显示器观察CRT图像。左侧CRT显示器分为两部分,显示两张经过与FCR硬拷贝相同图像处理的图像。右侧CRT显示器分为四部分,显示四张图像作为辅助诊断。上面两张图像用于诊断心脏和膈肌区域的结节,下面两张图像用于诊断肺野的结节。结果总结如下:1)CRT图像的敏感性(78.5%)优于其他图像,FCR硬拷贝的特异性(95.9%)更高。2) 对于直径5毫米和8毫米的结节检测准确性,三种模式之间没有显著差异。3) 数字化X光片(FCR为44.4%,CRT图像为54.4%)对直径3毫米结节检测的诊断准确性明显高于传统X光片(17.7%)。(摘要截短于250字)