Curran Vernon, Reid Adam, Reis Pamela, Doucet Shelley, Price Sheri, Alcock Lindsay, Fitzgerald Shari
a Faculty of Medicine , Centre for Collaborative Health Professional Education, Memorial University , St. John's , Newfoundland , Canada .
b College of Nursing, East Carolina University , Greensville , VA , USA .
J Interprof Care. 2015;29(6):541-50. doi: 10.3109/13561820.2015.1021002. Epub 2015 May 8.
Interprofessional education (IPE) in health and human services educational and clinical settings has proliferated internationally. The use of information and communication technologies (ICTs) in the facilitation of interprofessional learning is also growing, yet reviews of the effectiveness of ICTs in the delivery of pre- and/or post-licensure IPE have been limited. The current study's purpose was to review the evaluation outcomes of IPE initiatives delivered using ICTs. Relevant electronic databases and journals from 1996 to 2013 were searched. Studies which evaluated the effectiveness of an IPE intervention using ICTs were included and analyzed using the Barr et al. modified Kirkpatrick educational outcomes typology. Fifty-five studies were identified and a majority reported evaluation findings at the level 1 (reaction/satisfaction). Analysis revealed that learners react favorably to the use of ICTs in the delivery of IPE, and ICT-mediated IPE can lead to positive attitudinal and knowledge change. A majority of the studies reported positive evaluation outcomes at the learner satisfaction level, with the use of web-based learning modalities. The limited number of studies at other levels of the outcomes typology and deficiencies in study designs indicate the need for more rigorous evaluation of outcomes in ICT-mediated IPE.
卫生与人类服务教育及临床环境中的跨专业教育(IPE)已在国际上广泛开展。利用信息和通信技术(ICT)促进跨专业学习的情况也日益增多,然而,关于ICT在提供执照前和/或执照后IPE方面有效性的综述却很有限。本研究的目的是回顾使用ICT开展的IPE项目的评估结果。检索了1996年至2013年的相关电子数据库和期刊。纳入了评估使用ICT进行IPE干预有效性的研究,并使用Barr等人修改后的柯克帕特里克教育成果分类法进行分析。共识别出55项研究,其中大多数报告了1级(反应/满意度)的评估结果。分析表明,学习者对在IPE中使用ICT反应良好,且ICT介导的IPE可导致积极的态度和知识变化。大多数研究报告了在学习者满意度层面的积极评估结果,采用的是基于网络的学习方式。在成果分类法其他层面的研究数量有限以及研究设计存在缺陷,表明需要对ICT介导的IPE成果进行更严格的评估。