Omar Mohamed, Chaparala Hemant, Monga Manoj, Sivalingam Sri
Department of Urology, Glickman Urological and Kidney Institute , The Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio.
J Endourol. 2015 Oct;29(10):1122-5. doi: 10.1089/end.2015.0088. Epub 2015 Jun 30.
Routine imaging following ureteroscopy for treatment of renal/ureteral calculi continues to be a topic of debate. However, with the increasing focus on healthcare costs and quality, judicious use of diagnostic imaging to optimize outcomes while minimizing resource utilization is a priority. We sought to identify post-ureteroscopy imaging practices among experienced urologists.
A REDcap questionnaire was sent to urologists in North America. The questionnaire surveyed demographic data, clinical volume, and imaging preferences post-ureteroscopy. Additionally, we surveyed the extent to which stone, anatomic, and procedure-related factors influenced these preferences. The likelihood of altering clinical practice and the desire for specific imaging guidelines were also assessed. The interquartile range (IQR) was utilized as a measure of median consensus.
Three hundred twenty-two urologists completed the questionnaire. The mean number of years in practice was 18 ± 10; 82% of respondents performed more than five ureteroscopic stone procedures monthly. Routine postoperative imaging was obtained by 48% of participants as follows: ultrasound (US) (47%), kidneys, ureters, and bladder (KUB) (17%), CT (4%), intravenous pyelogram (IVP) (2%), and KUB+US (30%). Urologists who did not routinely image patients were more concerned about cost (55% vs 25%, p ≤ 0.0001), radiation exposure (69% vs 44%, p ≤ 0.0001), and diagnostic inaccuracy of US (57% vs 44%, p ≤ 0.02). These urologists were also less likely to have completed an endourology fellowship (7% vs 23%, p ≤ 0.0001). The most compelling predictors of obtaining postoperative imaging were postoperative pain and fever (median 5, IQR 1), residual stones (median 5, IQR 1), ureteral perforation (median 5, IQR 2), and presence of a solitary kidney (median 4.5, IQR 2).
Currently, about 50% of urologists who regularly perform ureteroscopic stone procedures obtain postoperative imaging. Imaging preferences were guided by the presence of residual fragments, ureteral perforation, solitary kidney, and postoperative pain or fever.
输尿管镜检查治疗肾/输尿管结石后的常规影像学检查仍是一个有争议的话题。然而,随着对医疗成本和质量的关注度不断提高,明智地使用诊断性影像学检查以优化治疗效果同时减少资源利用成为当务之急。我们试图确定经验丰富的泌尿外科医生在输尿管镜检查后的影像学检查实践。
向北美地区的泌尿外科医生发送了一份REDcap调查问卷。该问卷调查了人口统计学数据、临床工作量以及输尿管镜检查后的影像学检查偏好。此外,我们还调查了结石、解剖结构和手术相关因素对这些偏好的影响程度。还评估了改变临床实践的可能性以及对特定影像学检查指南的需求。四分位间距(IQR)被用作衡量中位数共识的指标。
322名泌尿外科医生完成了问卷。平均从业年限为18±10年;82%的受访者每月进行超过5例输尿管镜取石手术。48%的参与者进行了常规术后影像学检查,具体如下:超声(US)(47%)、肾脏输尿管膀胱平片(KUB)(17%)、CT(4%)、静脉肾盂造影(IVP)(2%)以及KUB+US(30%)。不常规对患者进行影像学检查的泌尿外科医生更关注成本(55%对25%,p≤0.0001)、辐射暴露(69%对44%,p≤0.0001)以及超声诊断不准确(57%对44%,p≤0.02)。这些泌尿外科医生完成腔内泌尿外科进修的可能性也较小(7%对23%,p≤0.0001)。进行术后影像学检查最具说服力的预测因素是术后疼痛和发热(中位数5,IQR 1)、残余结石(中位数5,IQR 1)、输尿管穿孔(中位数5,IQR 2)以及单肾情况(中位数4.5,IQR 2)。
目前,约50%经常进行输尿管镜取石手术的泌尿外科医生会进行术后影像学检查。影像学检查偏好受残余碎片、输尿管穿孔、单肾情况以及术后疼痛或发热的影响。