Layton Danielle
Int J Prosthodont. 2015 May-Jun;28(3):315-22. doi: 10.11607/ijp.2015.3.stat.
This survey aimed to review how scientific articles were reported and to describe the types of statistical tests that had been recently and commonly used in The International Journal of Prosthodontics.
All 174 articles published in 2012 and 2013 were hand-searched to identify scientific articles (n = 151) and those using at least one statistical test to explore results (n = 111). Editorials, letters, comments, erratum, and award proceedings were excluded. The number and type of statistical tests used within articles were collated, and the 10 commonly used methods were identified and described.
Of the 151 scientific articles, 76% (n = 111) used at least one statistical test and 24% (n = 40) used qualitative methods. Up to 10 tests were used per article, with 237 in total, of which 36 were unique. The 10 most commonly used tests were analysis of variance (ANOVA; n = 34), survival analyses (n = 29), Student t test (n = 19), chi-square (n = 19), Mann-Whitney U (n = 14), logistic regression (n = 13), Wilcoxon signed rank (n = 12), Fisher exact (n = 11), log-rank (n = 10), and Cox proportional hazards (n = 8), and they accounted for 71% (n = 169) of all tests used.
The vast majority of articles published in recent years in The International Journal of Prosthodontics employed statistical analyses. Across 2 years, nearly 250 tests were completed, including 36 unique tests. Statistical test use was common but diverse.
本调查旨在回顾科学文章的报告方式,并描述《国际口腔修复学杂志》近期常用的统计检验类型。
对2012年和2013年发表的所有174篇文章进行人工检索,以识别科学文章(n = 151)以及那些使用至少一种统计检验来探索结果的文章(n = 111)。社论、信件、评论、勘误和颁奖程序均被排除。整理文章中使用的统计检验的数量和类型,确定并描述10种常用方法。
在151篇科学文章中,76%(n = 111)使用了至少一种统计检验,24%(n = 40)使用了定性方法。每篇文章最多使用10种检验,总共237种,其中36种是独特的。10种最常用的检验是方差分析(ANOVA;n = 34)、生存分析(n = 29)、学生t检验(n = 19)、卡方检验(n = 19)、曼-惠特尼U检验(n = 14)、逻辑回归(n = 13)、威尔科克森符号秩检验(n = 12)、费舍尔精确检验(n = 11)、对数秩检验(n = 10)和考克斯比例风险模型(n = 8),它们占所有使用检验的71%(n = 169)。
近年来在《国际口腔修复学杂志》上发表的绝大多数文章都采用了统计分析。在两年时间里,完成了近250次检验,包括36种独特的检验。统计检验的使用很普遍但也多种多样。