Dagher Rada K, Chen Jie, Thomas Stephen B
Department of Health Services Administration, School of Public Health, University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2015 May 13;10(5):e0124103. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0124103. eCollection 2015.
We examined gender differences in mental health outcomes during and post-recession versus pre-recession. We utilized 2005-2006, 2008-2009, and 2010-2011 data from the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey. Females had lower odds of depression diagnoses during and post-recession and better mental health during the recession, but higher odds of anxiety diagnoses post-recession. Males had lower odds of depression diagnoses and better mental health during and post-recession and lower Kessler 6 scores post-recession. We conducted stratified analyses, which confirmed that the aforementioned findings were consistent across the four different regions of the U.S., by employment status, income and health care utilization. Importantly, we found that the higher odds of anxiety diagnoses among females after the recession were mainly prominent among specific subgroups of females: those who lived in the Northeast or the Midwest, the unemployed, and those with low household income. Gender differences in mental health in association with the economic recession highlight the importance of policymakers taking these differences into consideration when designing economic and social policies to address economic downturns. Future research should examine the reasons behind the decreased depression diagnoses among both genders, and whether they signify decreased mental healthcare utilization or increased social support and more time for exercise and leisure activities.
我们研究了经济衰退期间及之后与衰退之前心理健康结果的性别差异。我们使用了医疗支出面板调查2005 - 2006年、2008 - 2009年和2010 - 2011年的数据。女性在经济衰退期间及之后被诊断出抑郁症的几率较低,在衰退期间心理健康状况较好,但在衰退后被诊断出焦虑症的几率较高。男性在经济衰退期间及之后被诊断出抑郁症的几率较低,心理健康状况较好,且在衰退后凯斯勒6项量表得分较低。我们进行了分层分析,证实上述发现在美国四个不同地区、不同就业状况、收入和医疗保健利用率的人群中都是一致的。重要的是,我们发现衰退后女性中焦虑症诊断几率较高的情况主要在特定的女性亚组中较为突出:居住在东北部或中西部的女性、失业女性以及家庭收入较低的女性。与经济衰退相关的心理健康方面的性别差异凸显了政策制定者在设计应对经济衰退的经济和社会政策时考虑这些差异的重要性。未来的研究应该探讨两性抑郁症诊断率下降背后的原因,以及这是否意味着心理保健利用率下降或社会支持增加以及有更多时间进行锻炼和休闲活动。