Ding Xi-bin, Liu Fei, Zhang Chu, He Yong
Guang Pu Xue Yu Guang Pu Fen Xi. 2015 Feb;35(2):486-91.
In the present work, prediction models of SPAD value (Soil and Plant Analyzer Development, often used as a parameter to indicate chlorophyll content) in oilseed rape leaves were successfully built using hyperspectral imaging technique. The hy perspectral images of 160 oilseed rape leaf samples in the spectral range of 380-1030 nm were acquired. Average spectrum was extracted from the region of interest (ROI) of each sample. We chose spectral data in the spectral range of 500-900 nm for analysis. Using Monte Carlo partial least squares(MC-PLS) algorithm, 13 samples were identified as outliers and eliminated. Based on the spectral information and measured SPAD values of the rest 147 samples, several estimation models have been built based on different parameters using different algorithms for comparison, including: (1) a SPAD value estimation model based on partial least squares(PLS) in the whole wavelength region of 500-900 nm; (2) a SPAD value estimation model based on successive projections algorithmcombined with PLS(SPA-PLS); (3) 4 kind of simple experience SPAD value estimation models in which red edge position was used as an argument; (4) 4 kind of simple experience SPAD value estimation models in which three vegetation indexes R710/R760, (R750-R705)/(R750-R705) and R860/(R550 x R708), which all have been proved to have a good relevance with chlorophyll content, were used as an argument respectively; (5) a SPAD value estimation model based on PLS using the 3 vegetation indexes mentioned above. The results indicate that the optimal prediction performance is achieved by PLS model in the whole wavelength region of 500-900 nm, which has a correlation coefficient(r(p)) of 0.8339 and a root mean squares error of predicted (RMSEP) of 1.52. The SPA-PLS model can provide avery close prediction result while the calibration computation has been significantly reduced and the calibration speed has been accelerated sharply. For simple experience models based on red edge parameters and vegetation indexes, although there is a slight gap between theprediction performance and that of the PLS model in the whole wavelength region of 500-900 nm, they also have their own unique advantages which should be thought highly of: these models are much simpler and thus the calibration computation is reduced significantly, they can perform an important function under circumstances in which increasing modeling speed and reducing calibration computation operand are more important than improving the prediction accuracy, such as the development of portable devices.
在本研究中,利用高光谱成像技术成功建立了油菜叶片SPAD值(土壤和植物分析仪开发值,常作为指示叶绿素含量的参数)预测模型。采集了160个油菜叶片样本在380 - 1030 nm光谱范围内的高光谱图像。从每个样本的感兴趣区域(ROI)提取平均光谱。我们选择500 - 900 nm光谱范围内的光谱数据进行分析。使用蒙特卡罗偏最小二乘法(MC - PLS)算法,识别并剔除了13个样本作为异常值。基于其余147个样本的光谱信息和实测SPAD值,使用不同算法基于不同参数建立了多个估计模型进行比较,包括:(1)基于500 - 900 nm全波长区域偏最小二乘法(PLS)的SPAD值估计模型;(2)基于连续投影算法结合PLS(SPA - PLS)的SPAD值估计模型;(3)4种以红边位置为自变量的简单经验SPAD值估计模型;(4)4种分别以3种植被指数R710/R760、(R750 - R705)/(R750 - R705)和R860/(R550×R708)为自变量的简单经验SPAD值估计模型,这3种植被指数均已被证明与叶绿素含量有良好的相关性;(5)基于上述3种植被指数的PLS的SPAD值估计模型。结果表明,在500 - 900 nm全波长区域的PLS模型具有最佳预测性能,其相关系数(r(p))为0.8339,预测均方根误差(RMSEP)为1.52。SPA - PLS模型能提供非常接近的预测结果,同时校准计算量显著减少,校准速度大幅加快。对于基于红边参数和植被指数的简单经验模型,尽管其预测性能与500 - 900 nm全波长区域的PLS模型相比存在一定差距,但它们也有自身独特优势,应予以高度重视:这些模型更为简单,校准计算量显著减少,在提高建模速度和减少校准计算量比提高预测精度更重要的情况下,如便携式设备开发中,能发挥重要作用。