Hallett Nutmeg, Dickens Geoffrey L
St Andrew's, Northampton, UK.
Int J Ment Health Nurs. 2015 Aug;24(4):324-33. doi: 10.1111/inm.12136. Epub 2015 May 14.
De-escalation is an important tool for preventing aggression in inpatient settings but definitions vary and there is no clear practice guideline. We aimed to identify how clinical staff define and conceptualize de-escalation, which de-escalation interventions they would use in aggressive scenarios, and their beliefs about the efficacy of de-escalation interventions. A questionnaire survey (n = 72) was conducted using open and closed questions; additionally, clinical vignettes describing conflict events were presented for participants to describe their likely clinical response. Qualitative data were subject to thematic analysis. The major themes that de-escalation encompassed were communication, tactics, de-escalator qualities, assessment and risk, getting help, and containment measures. Different types of aggression were met with different interventions. Half of participants erroneously identified p.r.n. medication as a de-escalation intervention, and 15% wrongly stated that seclusion, restraint, and emergency i.m. medication could be de-escalation interventions. Those interventions seen as most effective were the most commonly used. Clinical staff's views about de-escalation, and their de-escalation practice, may differ from optimal practice. Use of containment measures and p.r.n. medication where de-escalation is more appropriate could have a negative impact; work is needed to promote understanding and use of appropriate de-escalation interventions based on a clear guideline.
降级处理是防止住院环境中攻击行为的一项重要手段,但相关定义各不相同,且尚无明确的实践指南。我们旨在确定临床工作人员如何定义和理解降级处理,在攻击场景中他们会采用哪些降级处理干预措施,以及他们对降级处理干预措施效果的看法。通过使用开放式和封闭式问题进行了一项问卷调查(n = 72);此外,还向参与者展示了描述冲突事件的临床案例,以让他们描述可能的临床反应。对定性数据进行了主题分析。降级处理涵盖的主要主题包括沟通、策略、降级处理人员的素质、评估与风险、寻求帮助以及控制措施。针对不同类型的攻击行为采用了不同的干预措施。一半的参与者错误地将按需用药视为一种降级处理干预措施,15%的人错误地表示隔离、约束和紧急肌内注射用药可能是降级处理干预措施。那些被视为最有效的干预措施也是最常用的。临床工作人员对降级处理的看法及其降级处理实践可能与最佳实践有所不同。在更适合进行降级处理的情况下使用控制措施和按需用药可能会产生负面影响;需要开展工作,以促进基于明确指南对适当降级处理干预措施的理解和使用。