Brenner Jay M, Kent Paul, Wojcik Susan M, Grant William
State University of New York Upstate Medical University, Departments of Emergency Medicine and Neurology, Syracuse, New York.
West J Emerg Med. 2015 May;16(3):442-6. doi: 10.5811/westjem.2015.3.24137. Epub 2015 Apr 6.
Electroencephalography (EEG) is indicated for diagnosing nonconvulsive status epilepticus (NCSE) in a patient who has altered level of consciousness after a motor seizure. A study in a neonatal population found 94% sensitivity and 78% specificity for detection of seizure using a single-lead device. This study aims to show that a reduced montage EEG would detect 90% of seizures detected on standard EEG.
A portable Brainmaster EEG device was available in the emergency department (ED) at all times. Patients presenting to the ED with altered mental status and known history of seizure or a witnessed seizure having a standard EEG were eligible for this study. The emergency physician obtained informed consent from the legally authorized representative (LAR), while an ED technician attached the electrodes to the patient, and a research associate attached the electrodes to the wiring routing to the portable EEG module. A board-certified epileptologist interpreted the tracings via the Internet. Simultaneously, the emergency physician ordered a standard 23-lead EEG, which would be interpreted by the neurologist on call to read EEGs. We compared the epileptologist's interpretation of the reduced montage EEG to the results of the 23-lead EEG, which was considered the gold standard for detecting seizures.
Twelve of 12 patients or 100% had the same findings on reduced-montage EEG as standard EEG. One of 12 patients or 8% had nonconvulsive seizure activity.
The results are consistent with prior studies which have shown that 8-48% of patients who have had a motor seizure continue to have nonconvulsive seizure activity on EEG. This study suggests that a bedside reduced-montage EEG can be used to make the diagnosis of NCSE in the ED. Further study will be conducted to see if this technology can be applied to the inpatient neurological intensive care unit setting.
脑电图(EEG)适用于诊断运动性癫痫发作后意识水平改变的患者的非惊厥性癫痫持续状态(NCSE)。一项针对新生儿群体的研究发现,使用单导联设备检测癫痫发作的敏感性为94%,特异性为78%。本研究旨在表明,简化导联脑电图能够检测出标准脑电图所检测到的90%的癫痫发作。
急诊科(ED)随时都有一台便携式Brainmaster脑电图设备。因精神状态改变前来急诊科就诊且有癫痫发作史或有目击癫痫发作并接受标准脑电图检查的患者符合本研究条件。急诊医生从法定授权代表(LAR)处获得知情同意,同时急诊科技术人员将电极连接到患者身上,研究助理将电极连接到通往便携式脑电图模块的线路上。一名获得委员会认证的癫痫专家通过互联网解读脑电图记录。同时,急诊医生开出标准的23导联脑电图检查单,由随叫随到的神经科医生解读脑电图。我们将癫痫专家对简化导联脑电图的解读结果与23导联脑电图的结果进行比较,23导联脑电图被视为检测癫痫发作的金标准。
12名患者中有12名(100%)在简化导联脑电图上的结果与标准脑电图相同。12名患者中有1名(8%)有非惊厥性癫痫活动。
这些结果与先前的研究一致,先前的研究表明,8%至48%有运动性癫痫发作的患者脑电图上仍有非惊厥性癫痫活动。本研究表明,床边简化导联脑电图可用于急诊科诊断NCSE。将进一步开展研究,以确定该技术是否可应用于住院患者的神经重症监护病房。