Soong Andrea, Chen Julia Cen, Borzekowski Dina Lg
Institute for Global Tobacco Control, Department of Health, Behavior & Society, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, MD, United States.
JMIR Res Protoc. 2015 Jun 24;4(2):e76. doi: 10.2196/resprot.4408.
Ecological momentary assessment (EMA) uses real-time data collection to assess participants' behaviors and environments. This paper explores the strengths and limitations of using EMA to examine social and environmental exposure to tobacco in urban India among older adolescents and adults.
Objectives of this study were (1) to describe the methods used in an EMA study of tobacco use in urban India using a mobile phone app for data collection, (2) to determine the feasibility of using EMA in the chosen setting by drawing on participant completion and compliance rates with the study protocol, and (3) to provide recommendations on implementing mobile phone EMA research in India and other low- and middle-income countries.
Via mobile phones and the Internet, this study used two EMA surveys: (1) a momentary survey, sent multiple times per day at random to participants, which asked about their real-time tobacco use (smoked and smokeless) and exposure to pro- and antitobacco messaging in their location, and 2) an end-of-day survey sent at the end of each study day. Trained participants, from Hyderabad and Kolkata, India, reported on their social and environmental exposure to tobacco over 10 consecutive days. This feasibility study examined participant compliance, exploring factors related to the successful completion of surveys and the validity of EMA data.
The sample included 205 participants, the majority of whom were male (135/205, 65.9%). Almost half smoked less than daily (56/205, 27.3%) or daily (43/205, 21.0%), and 4.4% (9/205) used smokeless tobacco products. Participants completed and returned 46.87% and 73.02% of momentary and end-of-day surveys, respectively. Significant predictors of momentary survey completion included employment and completion of end-of-day surveys. End-of-day survey completion was only significantly predicted by momentary survey completion.
This first study of EMA in India offers promising results, although more research is needed on how to increase compliance. End-of-day survey completion, which has a lower research burden, may be the more appropriate approach to understanding behaviors such as tobacco use within vulnerable populations in challenging locations. Compliance may also be improved by increasing the number of study visits, compliance checks, or opportunities for retraining participants before and during data collection.
生态瞬时评估(EMA)利用实时数据收集来评估参与者的行为和环境。本文探讨了在印度城市地区的青少年和成年人中,使用EMA研究烟草的社会和环境暴露情况的优势与局限性。
本研究的目的包括:(1)描述在印度城市地区一项使用手机应用程序进行数据收集的烟草使用EMA研究中所采用的方法;(2)通过参考参与者对研究方案的完成率和依从率,确定在选定环境中使用EMA的可行性;(3)为在印度以及其他低收入和中等收入国家开展手机EMA研究提供建议。
本研究通过手机和互联网进行了两项EMA调查:(1)瞬时调查,每天随机向参与者发送多次,询问他们实时的烟草使用情况(吸烟和无烟烟草)以及在其所在地点接触支持和反对烟草信息的情况;(2)每天结束时发送的每日结束调查。来自印度海得拉巴和加尔各答的经过培训的参与者连续10天报告他们在社会和环境方面接触烟草的情况。这项可行性研究考察了参与者的依从性,探讨了与成功完成调查以及EMA数据有效性相关的因素。
样本包括205名参与者,其中大多数为男性(135/205,65.9%)。几乎一半的人吸烟频率低于每日一次(56/205,27.3%)或每日一次(43/205,21.0%),4.4%(9/205)使用无烟烟草产品。参与者分别完成并返回了46.87%的瞬时调查和73.02%的每日结束调查。瞬时调查完成情况的显著预测因素包括就业情况和每日结束调查的完成情况。每日结束调查的完成情况仅由瞬时调查的完成情况显著预测。
印度的这项EMA首次研究取得了有前景的结果,不过在如何提高依从性方面还需要更多研究。每日结束调查的研究负担较低,可能是了解在具有挑战性地区的弱势群体中烟草使用等行为的更合适方法。还可以通过增加研究访视次数、依从性检查或在数据收集之前和期间对参与者进行再培训的机会来提高依从性。