Bagheri Pezhman, Mohammadi Mohammad Reza, Shafiei Nematollah
Jiroft University of Medical Sciences, Jiroft, Iran.
School of Medicine, Department of Social Medicine, Fasa University of Medical Science, Ibn-e-Sina Square, 7461686688, Fasa, Fars Province, Iran.
J Relig Health. 2017 Jun;56(3):755-775. doi: 10.1007/s10943-015-0078-6.
Several documents have investigated the area of Quran study and medicine from different points of view; the present study has been assessing all the documents about Quran study and medicine, published in Iranian scientific-research journals, to create an opportunity of revising the interventions executed in this areas and targeting the decisions in order to draw a clear and more realistic vision. In this simple review study, scientific-research and general informative websites in the period of 1992-2013 were explored by taking advantage of critical keywords such as Islamic medicine and Islamic lifestyle. After the initial retrieval, 348 articles were finally ready for the evaluation process. Chi-square test was used to assess the significance of patterns differences between years of study. Minimum and maximum numbers of articles were published in 1992 (0.28 %) and 2011 (12.35 %), respectively. The level of execution of studies by using different methods was as follows: about 3.44 % qualitative, 29.59 % cross-sectional descriptive-analytical, 30.45 % review, 1.14 % case-control, 17.52 % experimental, 3.73 % cohort methods and 12.93 % were performed by other methods. The most common subject study was "The effects of fasting and Ramadan on health" (21.83 %). The most important journals hosting this field articles were the journals of medicine and refinement (27.01 %), as well as the Quran and medicine (12.64 %), respectively. Chi-square test showed significant thematic differences during the 21 years of study. Based on the available evidences, the number of descriptive papers was yet more than the analytical, interventional and scientific-comparative articles. Also, the most studies had been reviewing the medical-Islamic documents. This reflects the need for revising the search strategies of Quran study and medicine.
已有多篇文献从不同角度对《古兰经》研究与医学领域进行了探讨;本研究评估了伊朗科研期刊上发表的所有关于《古兰经》研究与医学的文献,旨在为修正该领域已实施的干预措施及制定决策创造机会,从而勾勒出清晰且更现实的图景。在这项简单的综述研究中,利用“伊斯兰医学”和“伊斯兰生活方式”等关键检索词,对1992年至2013年期间的科研及综合信息网站进行了探索。经过初步检索,最终有348篇文章进入评估流程。采用卡方检验来评估各研究年份之间模式差异的显著性。发表文章数量最少和最多的年份分别是1992年(0.28%)和2011年(12.35%)。采用不同方法开展研究的执行水平如下:定性研究约占3.44%,横断面描述性分析占29.59%,综述占30.45%,病例对照研究占1.14%,实验研究占17.52%,队列研究方法占3.73%,其他方法占12.93%。最常见的主题研究是“禁食和斋月对健康的影响”(21.83%)。刊载该领域文章的最重要期刊分别是医学与修养期刊(27.01%)以及《古兰经》与医学期刊(12.64%)。卡方检验显示,在21年的研究期间存在显著的主题差异。基于现有证据,描述性论文的数量仍多于分析性、干预性和科学比较性文章。此外,大多数研究一直在对伊斯兰医学文献进行综述。这反映出有必要修正《古兰经》研究与医学的检索策略。