Novak Mario
School of Archaeology, University College Dublin, Belfield, Dublin 4, Ireland; Institute for Anthropological Research, Ulica Ljudevita Gaja 32, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia.
Arch Oral Biol. 2015 Sep;60(9):1299-309. doi: 10.1016/j.archoralbio.2015.06.004. Epub 2015 Jun 18.
With the aim to get a better picture of dental health, diet and nutrition in early medieval Ireland a population-based study focusing on several attributes of oral health in adult individuals was conducted. The study focused on possible differences between sexes and age groups in terms of frequency and distribution of studied pathologies in order to determine whether these differences result from different diets, cultural practices or are age-related.
Permanent dentitions belonging to adult individuals from five Irish early medieval sites were examined for the evidence of caries, ante-mortem tooth loss, abscesses, calculus, alveolar bone resorption and tooth wear. All pathologies were analysed and presented by teeth and alveoli.
A total of 3233 teeth and 3649 alveoli belonging to 167 individuals (85 males and 82 females) were included into the analysis. Males exhibited significantly higher prevalence of abscesses, heavy wear and alveolar bone resorption, while females exhibited significantly higher prevalence of calculus. All studied dento-alveolar pathologies showed a strong correlation with advanced age, except calculus in females. Additionally, dental wear associated with habitual activities was observed in two females.
The results of the present study confirm the data gained by written sources and stable isotopes analyses suggesting the diet of the early Irish was rich in carbohydrates with only occasional use of meat. Furthermore, significant differences between the sexes in terms of recorded pathologies strongly suggest different nutritional patterns with females consuming foods mostly based on carbohydrates in comparison to males. The observed sex-differences might also occur due to differences between male and female sex such as reproductive biology and pregnancy, a somewhat different age distributions, but also as a result of different cultural practices between the sexes.
为了更全面地了解中世纪早期爱尔兰的牙齿健康、饮食和营养状况,开展了一项基于人群的研究,重点关注成年个体口腔健康的几个特征。该研究聚焦于不同性别和年龄组在所研究病变的频率和分布方面可能存在的差异,以确定这些差异是源于不同的饮食、文化习俗还是与年龄相关。
对来自爱尔兰五个中世纪早期遗址的成年个体的恒牙列进行检查,以寻找龋齿、生前牙齿脱落、脓肿、牙结石、牙槽骨吸收和牙齿磨损的证据。所有病变均按牙齿和牙槽进行分析和呈现。
分析纳入了属于167名个体(85名男性和82名女性)的总共3233颗牙齿和3649个牙槽。男性的脓肿、重度磨损和牙槽骨吸收患病率显著更高,而女性的牙结石患病率显著更高。除女性的牙结石外,所有研究的牙-牙槽病变都与高龄密切相关。此外,在两名女性中观察到与习惯性活动相关的牙齿磨损。
本研究结果证实了书面资料和稳定同位素分析所获得的数据,表明早期爱尔兰人的饮食富含碳水化合物,仅偶尔食用肉类。此外,在所记录的病变方面,两性之间存在显著差异,这强烈表明两性的营养模式不同,与男性相比,女性食用的食物大多以碳水化合物为主。观察到的性别差异也可能是由于男女生殖生物学和怀孕等性别差异、年龄分布略有不同,以及两性之间不同的文化习俗所致。