Ham Allison C
Department of Anthropology, Penn State University, University Park, Pennsylvania, USA.
Am J Biol Anthropol. 2025 Apr;186(4):e70040. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.70040.
This study evaluates the effect of sex on mortality risks in medieval Ireland to advance our understanding of the social, biological, and environmental factors that were deleterious to female health and survival in the past.
Data on age-at-death and sex was collected on 335 skeletonized individuals from 10 archaeological sites dating to the early medieval (500-1150 ce) and late medieval (1150-1550 ce) periods in Ireland. Transition analysis (TA2) was used to estimate age-at-death for all individuals with visibly fused pelvic and long bone epiphyses. For all other individuals, age-at-death was estimated using dental development and epiphyseal fusion. Morphological traits of the pelvis and cranium and metric measurements were used to estimate sex. A Gompertz-Makeham hazards model with a proportional hazards specification was used to examine the effect of the sex covariate on mortality risks.
The Gompertz-Makeham hazards model failed to reveal an effect of sex on mortality risks in this context. No significant temporal variation in the effect of sex on the model was observed across sites.
The results failed to find an effect of the sex covariate on the mortality profile using hazards analysis. However, the similar mortality profiles observed between medieval Irish males and females could reflect cultural barriers and/or differential environmental exposures that counteracted the innate female survival advantage observed today.
本研究评估性别对中世纪爱尔兰死亡率风险的影响,以增进我们对过去对女性健康和生存有害的社会、生物和环境因素的理解。
收集了来自爱尔兰10个考古遗址的335具骨骼个体的死亡年龄和性别的数据,这些遗址可追溯到中世纪早期(公元500 - 1150年)和中世纪晚期(公元1150 - 1550年)。对于所有骨盆和长骨骺明显融合的个体,使用过渡分析(TA2)来估计死亡年龄。对于所有其他个体,使用牙齿发育和骨骺融合来估计死亡年龄。骨盆和颅骨的形态特征以及测量数据用于估计性别。使用具有比例风险规范的冈珀茨 - 马凯姆风险模型来检验性别协变量对死亡率风险的影响。
在这种情况下,冈珀茨 - 马凯姆风险模型未能揭示性别对死亡率风险的影响。在各遗址中,未观察到性别对模型影响的显著时间变化。
结果未能通过风险分析发现性别协变量对死亡率分布的影响。然而,中世纪爱尔兰男性和女性之间观察到的相似死亡率分布可能反映了文化障碍和/或不同的环境暴露,这些因素抵消了当今观察到的女性天生的生存优势。