Nystrom Lukas M, McKinley Todd O, Marsh J Lawrence
*Department of Orthopaedic Surgery and Rehabilitation, Loyola University Chicago, Maywood, IL; †Department of Orthopedics & Sports Medicine, Indiana University Health, Indianapolis, IN; and ‡Department of Orthopaedics & Rehabilitation, University of Iowa Hospitals & Clinics, Iowa City, IA.
J Orthop Trauma. 2015 Aug;29(8):365-9. doi: 10.1097/BOT.0000000000000306.
Measuring pelvic ring displacement on plain radiographs has focused on gap and translational displacements with little discussion of rotational displacement, likely because of measurement difficulties. Our hypothesis is that rotational displacement can be accurately measured on computer-reconstructed radiographs (CRRs) with good validity and reliability.
A Sawbones model was used to simulate common pelvic ring fracture patterns. CT scans were obtained and converted to CRRs simulating standard views. A technique of measuring axial rotation on the inlet view and sagittal rotation on the inlet/outlet views was developed. The novel rotational assessment techniques were then used by 8 senior orthopaedic residents and 3 fellowship-trained orthopaedic trauma surgeons on the CRR of each model. These measurements were then assessed for interobserver reliability and validity. Validity was tested by comparing the values obtained by the observers to the actual displacement as measured on CT scans.
Newly described techniques for axial and sagittal rotational measurements showed excellent reliability with average confidence intervals of 1.8° and 3.4°, respectively. There was good validity of the technique, with the majority of the "true" measurements falling within the 95% confidence interval of the observer measurements.
A new radiographic technique for measuring axial and sagittal rotational deformities shows excellent interobserver reliability and good validity. This technique offers a low-cost and low-radiation examination to assess this deformity, which is readily available in most clinical settings. This measurement system can be used in future clinical studies to assess the clinical implications of residual rotational displacement.
在普通X线片上测量骨盆环移位主要关注间隙和移位,而对旋转移位讨论较少,可能是由于测量困难。我们的假设是,旋转移位可以在计算机重建的X线片(CRR)上准确测量,具有良好的效度和信度。
使用Sawbones模型模拟常见的骨盆环骨折模式。获取CT扫描图像并转换为模拟标准视图的CRR。开发了一种在入口视图上测量轴向旋转和在入口/出口视图上测量矢状旋转的技术。然后,8名高级骨科住院医师和3名接受过研究员培训的骨科创伤外科医生在每个模型的CRR上使用这种新的旋转评估技术。然后评估这些测量结果的观察者间信度和效度。通过将观察者获得的值与CT扫描测量的实际移位进行比较来测试效度。
新描述的轴向和矢状旋转测量技术显示出极好的信度,平均置信区间分别为1.8°和3.4°。该技术具有良好的效度,大多数“真实”测量值落在观察者测量值的95%置信区间内。
一种测量轴向和矢状旋转畸形的新放射学技术显示出极好的观察者间信度和良好的效度。该技术提供了一种低成本、低辐射的检查方法来评估这种畸形,在大多数临床环境中都很容易获得。这种测量系统可用于未来的临床研究,以评估残余旋转移位的临床意义。