Public Health Policy Research Program, RTI International, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, USA.
Digital Technology and Society Program, Survey Research Division, RTI International, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, USA.
Tob Control. 2016 Apr;25(e1):e19-23. doi: 10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2015-052270. Epub 2015 Jul 23.
Although the overall impact of Electronic Nicotine Delivery Systems (ENDS) on public health is unclear, awareness, use, and marketing of the products have increased markedly in recent years. Identifying the increasing number of 'vape stores' that specialise in selling ENDS can be challenging given the lack of regulatory policies and licensing. This study assesses the utility of online search methods in identifying ENDS vape stores.
We conducted online searches in Google Maps, Yelp, and YellowPages to identify listings of ENDS vape stores in Florida, and used a crowdsourcing platform to call and verify stores that primarily sold ENDS to consumers. We compared store listings generated from the online search and crowdsourcing methodology to list licensed tobacco and ENDS retailers from the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation.
The combined results from all three online sources yielded a total of 403 ENDS vape stores. Nearly 32.5% of these stores were on the state tobacco licensure list, while 67.5% were not. Accuracy of online results was highest for Yelp (77.6%), followed by YellowPages (77.1%) and Google (53.0%).
Using the online search methodology we identified more ENDS vape stores than were on the state tobacco licensure list. This approach may be a promising strategy to identify and track the growth of ENDS vape stores over time, especially in states without a systematic licensing requirement for such stores.
尽管电子尼古丁传送系统(ENDS)对公众健康的整体影响尚不清楚,但近年来,人们对这些产品的认识、使用和营销显著增加。鉴于缺乏监管政策和许可,识别专门销售 ENDS 的“蒸汽烟商店”的数量不断增加具有挑战性。本研究评估了在线搜索方法在识别 ENDS 蒸汽烟商店方面的效用。
我们在 Google 地图、Yelp 和 YellowPages 上进行了在线搜索,以确定佛罗里达州 ENDS 蒸汽烟商店的列表,并使用众包平台致电并验证主要向消费者销售 ENDS 的商店。我们将在线搜索和众包方法生成的商店列表与佛罗里达州商业和专业监管部的持牌烟草和 ENDS 零售商列表进行了比较。
所有三个在线来源的综合结果共产生了 403 家 ENDS 蒸汽烟商店。这些商店中近 32.5%在州烟草许可名单上,而 67.5%不在名单上。Yelp 的在线结果准确率最高(77.6%),其次是 YellowPages(77.1%)和 Google(53.0%)。
使用在线搜索方法,我们确定的 ENDS 蒸汽烟商店比州烟草许可名单上的要多。这种方法可能是随着时间的推移识别和跟踪 ENDS 蒸汽烟商店增长的有前途的策略,特别是在没有对这些商店进行系统许可要求的州。