Henry David, Fok Carlotta Ching Ting, Allen James
Institute for Health Research and Policy, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, USA.
Center for Alaska Native Health Research, University of Alaska Fairbanks, Fairbanks, USA.
Prev Sci. 2015 Oct;16(7):1026-32. doi: 10.1007/s11121-015-0577-4.
Implications of the Advancing Small Sample Prevention Science Special Section are discussed. Efficiency and precision are inadequately considered in many current prevention-science methodological approaches. As a result, design and analytic practices pose difficulties for the study of contextual factors in prevention, which often involve small samples. Four primary conclusions can be drawn from the Special Section. First, contemporary statistical and measurement approaches provide a number of underutilized opportunities to maximize power. These strategies maximize efficiencies by optimizing design and resource allocation parameters, allowing for the detection of effects with small samples. Second, several alternative research designs provide both rigor and further optimize efficiencies through more complete use of available information, allowing study of important questions in prevention science for which only small samples may be accessible. Third, mixed methods hold promise for enhancing the utility of qualitative data in studies with small samples. Finally, Bayesian analytic approaches, through their use of prior information, allow for even greater efficiencies in work with small samples, and through their introduction in the routines of mainstream software packages, hold particular promise as an emergent methodology in prevention research.
本文讨论了推进小样本预防科学专题的意义。在当前许多预防科学方法论中,效率和精度未得到充分考虑。因此,设计和分析方法给预防中情境因素的研究带来了困难,而这些研究往往涉及小样本。该专题可得出四个主要结论。第一,当代统计和测量方法提供了许多未被充分利用的机会来最大化功效。这些策略通过优化设计和资源分配参数来提高效率,从而能够在小样本情况下检测出效应。第二,几种替代研究设计既严谨又通过更充分利用现有信息进一步提高了效率,使得能够研究预防科学中的重要问题,而这些问题可能只能获取小样本。第三,混合方法有望提高小样本研究中定性数据的效用。最后,贝叶斯分析方法通过使用先验信息,在小样本研究中能实现更高的效率,并且随着其被引入主流软件包的常规操作中,作为预防研究中一种新兴方法具有特别的前景。