Kiliçarslan Aydan, Süngü Nuran, Balci Serdar, Canda Erdem, Altinova Serkan, Güler Gülnur
Department of Pathology, Yıldırım Beyazıt University, Ankara Atatürk Training and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey.
Department of Urology, Yıldırım Beyazıt University, Ankara Atatürk Training and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey.
J Cytol. 2015 Apr-Jun;32(2):85-9. doi: 10.4103/0970-9371.160549.
Urinary cytology has low sensitivity and specificity in urinary neoplasm.
We planned to assess whether the examination of bladder washing before biopsy (WBB) plays a role in better cytologic diagnosis of bladder wash fluid collected after biopsy procedure (WAB) in papillary urothelial neoplasms.
We included 36 patients with papillary lesion of bladder. Prior to the biopsy, the bladder is washed and fluid is collected for cytology; later transurethral resection (TUR) is performed, then bladders are washed again and the fluid is separately collected for cytology. Both fluids were centrifuged and stained with May-Grünwald Giemsa (MGG). First the WAB slides were evaluated and diagnosed. After evaluation of the WBB slides, the WAB slides were rediagnosed. Presence of cellularity, papillary structure, fusiform cells, background bleeding, and cytolysis in WBB and WAB were evaluated separately.
We determined that 31 WBB samples were hypercellular, and 12 of them remained as hypercellular in WAB. Papillary structures were observed in 20 WBB samples; and in one WAB cytology. In 29 cases where no fusiform cells are identified in WBB, 22 showed fusiform cells in WAB. Cytolysis in WABs was noted in 15 cases whose WBBs did not show cytolysis. The decrease in cellularity, papillary structure (P < 0.001, both), cytolysis (P = 0.008), and fusiform cells (P < 0.001) were statistically significant. After seeing the WBB slides, we reevaluated the WAB slides. Out of the eight out of 36 (22.2%) samples diagnosed with degeneration previously, five (62.5%) samples were rediagnosed as benign, two (25%) as cytologic atypia which favor reactive, and one (12.5%) as malignant.
Due to the better quality, initial evaluation of WBB may help more effective diagnoses of WAB slides.
尿细胞学检查在泌尿系统肿瘤中敏感性和特异性较低。
我们计划评估活检前膀胱冲洗液检查(WBB)对乳头状尿路上皮肿瘤活检后膀胱冲洗液(WAB)的细胞学诊断是否有更好的作用。
我们纳入了36例膀胱乳头状病变患者。活检前,冲洗膀胱并收集冲洗液进行细胞学检查;随后进行经尿道切除术(TUR),然后再次冲洗膀胱并分别收集冲洗液进行细胞学检查。两种冲洗液均离心并用May-Grünwald Giemsa(MGG)染色。首先对WAB涂片进行评估和诊断。在评估WBB涂片后,对WAB涂片进行重新诊断。分别评估WBB和WAB中细胞成分、乳头状结构、梭形细胞、背景出血和细胞溶解的情况。
我们确定31份WBB样本细胞成分增多,其中12份在WAB中仍为细胞成分增多。在20份WBB样本中观察到乳头状结构;在1份WAB细胞学检查中观察到。在29例WBB中未发现梭形细胞的病例中,22例在WAB中显示有梭形细胞。15例WAB中有细胞溶解,其WBB中未显示细胞溶解。细胞成分、乳头状结构(均P<0.001)、细胞溶解(P=0.008)和梭形细胞(P<0.001)的减少具有统计学意义。在查看WBB涂片后,我们对WAB涂片进行了重新评估。在36例(22.2%)之前诊断为退变的样本中,8例中有5例(62.5%)重新诊断为良性,2例(25%)为倾向反应性的细胞学非典型性,1例(12.5%)为恶性。
由于质量更好,对WBB的初始评估可能有助于更有效地诊断WAB涂片。