Fusaro Maria, Dalle Carbonare Luca, Dusso Adriana, Arcidiacono Maria Vittoria, Valenti Maria Teresa, Aghi Andrea, Pasho Sabina, Gallieni Maurizio
National Research Council (CNR)-Neuroscience Institute, Padova, Italy.
Department of Medicine, Section of Internal Medicine D, University of Verona, Verona, Italy.
PLoS One. 2015 Aug 4;10(8):e0133847. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0133847. eCollection 2015.
Warfarin, a widely used anticoagulant, is a vitamin K antagonist impairing the activity of vitamin K-dependent Bone Gla Protein (BGP or Osteocalcin) and Matrix Gla Protein (MGP). Because dabigatran, a new anticoagulant, has no effect on vitamin K metabolism, the aim of this study was to compare the impact of warfarin and dabigatran administration on bone structure and vascular calcification.
Rats with normal renal function received for 6 weeks warfarin, dabigatran or placebo. Bone was evaluated immuno-histochemically and hystomorphometrically after double labelling with declomycin and calcein. Aorta and iliac arteries were examined histologically.
Histomorphometric analysis of femur and vertebrae showed significantly decreased bone volume and increased trabecular separation in rats treated with warfarin. Vertebra analysis showed that the trabecular number was higher in dabigatran treated rats. Osteoblast activity and resorption parameters were similar among groups, except for maximum erosion depth, which was higher in warfarin treated rats, suggesting a higher osteoclastic activity. Therefore, warfarin treatment was also associated with higher bone formation rate/bone surface and activation frequency. Warfarin treatment may cause an increased bone turnover characterized by increased remodelling cycles, with stronger osteoclast activity compared to the other groups. There were no differences among experimental groups in calcium deposition either in aortic or iliac arteries.
These findings suggest for the first time that dabigatran has a better bone safety profile than warfarin, as warfarin treatment affects bone by reducing trabecular size and structure, increasing turnover and reducing mineralization. These differences could potentially result in a lower incidence of fractures in dabigatran treated patients.
华法林是一种广泛使用的抗凝剂,是一种维生素K拮抗剂,会损害维生素K依赖的骨钙素(BGP或骨钙蛋白)和基质Gla蛋白(MGP)的活性。由于新型抗凝剂达比加群对维生素K代谢没有影响,本研究的目的是比较华法林和达比加群给药对骨结构和血管钙化的影响。
肾功能正常的大鼠接受6周的华法林、达比加群或安慰剂治疗。在用地美环素和钙黄绿素双重标记后,通过免疫组织化学和组织形态计量学评估骨骼。对主动脉和髂动脉进行组织学检查。
股骨和椎骨的组织形态计量学分析显示,接受华法林治疗的大鼠骨体积显著减少,小梁间距增加。椎骨分析表明,接受达比加群治疗的大鼠小梁数量更多。除最大侵蚀深度外,各组间成骨细胞活性和吸收参数相似,华法林治疗组的最大侵蚀深度更高,表明破骨细胞活性更高。因此,华法林治疗还与更高的骨形成率/骨表面积和激活频率相关。华法林治疗可能导致骨转换增加,其特征是重塑周期增加,与其他组相比破骨细胞活性更强。实验组在主动脉或髂动脉的钙沉积方面没有差异。
这些发现首次表明,达比加群的骨安全性优于华法林,因为华法林治疗通过减小小梁尺寸和结构、增加骨转换和减少矿化来影响骨骼。这些差异可能会导致达比加群治疗患者骨折发生率较低。