Palmgren Per J, Laksov Klara Bolander
Department of Learning, Informatics, Management and Ethics, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, 171 77, Sweden.
Department of Education, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden.
BMC Med Educ. 2015 Aug 5;15:128. doi: 10.1186/s12909-015-0417-z.
The educational environment has a significant impact on students' behavior, sense of well-being, and academic advancement. While various research methodologies have been used to explore the educational environment, there is a paucity of studies employing qualitative research methods. This study engages in an in-depth exploration of chiropractic students' experiences of the meaning of the educational environment.
A qualitative approach was employed by interviewing 26 students in four focus group interviews at two different points in time. A conventional manifest and latent content analysis was chosen to investigate and interpret the experiences of the educational environment in an undergraduate chiropractic training institution in Sweden.
The analysis resulted in five overarching themes: Personal growth; Being part of a community; A place of meaningfulness; Trust in a regulated system; and Scaffolding relationships. Early in the training, the meaning of the educational environment was experienced as part of a vocational community and the scaffolding of intra-institutional relationships. In later stages, the environment was experienced in terms of personal growth - balancing academic pressures and progress within the professional community - thus laying the foundations for autonomy and motivation. During the clinical training, the environment was experienced as where learning happens, thus creating a place of meaningfulness. Throughout the training, the formal and clinical environments were experienced as isolating, with little bridging between the two. A regulated system - conveying an operative organization with clear communication regarding what to expect - was experienced as important for an apt educational environment.
We found that experiences of an educational environment are dynamic and change over time. When restructuring or evaluating curriculums, educational managers can consider the emerged themes as constituting facets relating to the educational environment, and thus possible learning conditions. Likewise, researchers can consider these aspects of the educational environment when: interpreting results from quantitative and qualitative inquiries, constructing and refining instruments, or conceptualizing and framing the educational environment phenomenon.
教育环境对学生的行为、幸福感和学业进步有着重大影响。虽然已经使用了各种研究方法来探索教育环境,但采用定性研究方法的研究却很少。本研究深入探讨了脊骨神经医学专业学生对教育环境意义的体验。
采用定性研究方法,在两个不同时间点对26名学生进行了四次焦点小组访谈。选择了传统的显性和隐性内容分析法,以调查和解释瑞典一所本科脊骨神经医学培训机构中教育环境的体验。
分析得出了五个总体主题:个人成长;成为社区的一员;有意义的地方;对规范体系的信任;以及支持性的关系。在培训初期,教育环境的意义被体验为职业社区的一部分以及机构内关系的支持。在后期阶段,环境体验涉及个人成长——平衡学业压力和在专业社区内的进步——从而为自主性和动力奠定基础。在临床培训期间,环境被体验为学习发生的地方,从而创造了一个有意义的地方。在整个培训过程中,正式环境和临床环境被体验为相互隔离的,两者之间几乎没有衔接。一个规范的体系——传达一个运作组织,对预期内容有清晰的沟通——被认为对适宜的教育环境很重要。
我们发现教育环境的体验是动态的,会随着时间而变化。在重组或评估课程时,教育管理者可以将出现的主题视为与教育环境相关的方面,从而视为可能的学习条件。同样,研究人员在解释定量和定性调查结果、构建和完善工具或概念化和构建教育环境现象时,可以考虑教育环境的这些方面。