Sengupta Arkajyoti, Ramabhadran Raghunath O, Raghavachari Krishnan
Department of Chemistry, Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana, 47405.
J Comput Chem. 2016 Jan 15;37(2):286-95. doi: 10.1002/jcc.24050. Epub 2015 Aug 17.
Open Shell organic radicals are principal species involved in many diverse areas such as combustion, photochemistry, and polymer chemistry. Computational studies of such species with an accurate method like coupled-cluster with single and double and perturbative triple (CCSD(T)) may be restricted to systems of modest size due to the steep computational scaling of the method. Herein, we assess the accuracy of extrapolated CCSD(T) energies determined using the connectivity-based hierarchy (CBH) method on medium to large sized radicals. In our method, an MP2 calculation on the target radical is coupled with CCSD(T) energies of fragments determined uniquely by our hierarchy to perform accurate extrapolations. A careful assessment is done with a robust CBH-rad49 test set comprising of 49 diverse cyclic and acyclic radicals with a variety of functional groups. We demonstrate that the extrapolation method with CBH-2 or CBH-3 is sufficient to obtain sub-kcal accuracy. ROMP2 and PMP2 calculations with both Pople-style and Dunning-style basis-sets resulted in mean absolute errors for CCSD(T) extrapolation (full CCSD(T)-extrapolated CCSD(T)) within 0.5 kcal/mol. Further speedup for such CCSD(T) extrapolations are obtained with ROHF-based RI-MP2 calculations. Challenging systems with (a) high ring strain, (b) delocalized character, and (c) spin contamination are identified and analyzed in detail. Finally, we apply our extrapolation method on 10 larger radicals containing 10-15 heavy atoms, where accurate CCSD(T) energies are obtained at a fractional cost of full CCSD(T) calculations.
开壳层有机自由基是参与燃烧、光化学和聚合物化学等许多不同领域的主要物种。使用诸如单双和微扰三重耦合簇(CCSD(T))这样的精确方法对这类物种进行计算研究,可能会由于该方法陡峭的计算规模扩展而局限于中等规模的系统。在此,我们评估了使用基于连接性层次结构(CBH)方法确定的外推CCSD(T)能量在中等至大型自由基上的准确性。在我们的方法中,对目标自由基进行的MP2计算与由我们的层次结构唯一确定的片段的CCSD(T)能量相结合,以进行精确的外推。使用由49个具有各种官能团的不同环状和非环状自由基组成的强大的CBH-rad49测试集进行了仔细评估。我们证明,使用CBH-2或CBH-3的外推方法足以获得低于千卡的准确性。使用普适力场(Pople)风格和邓宁(Dunning)风格基组进行的ROMP2和PMP2计算,导致CCSD(T)外推(完整CCSD(T) - 外推CCSD(T))的平均绝对误差在0.5千卡/摩尔以内。基于ROHF的RI-MP2计算进一步加速了此类CCSD(T)外推。对具有(a)高环张力、(b)离域特征和(c)自旋污染的具有挑战性的系统进行了详细识别和分析。最后,我们将我们的外推方法应用于10个含有10 - 15个重原子的较大自由基,在这些自由基上以完整CCSD(T)计算成本的一小部分获得了精确的CCSD(T)能量。