Grignon Bruno, Oldrini Guillaume, Walter Frédéric
Département d'Anatomie Faculté de Médecine Université de Lorraine, Service Imagerie Guilloz, CHU Nancy, 29 av de Lattre de Tassigny, 54035, Nancy Cedex, France.
Service de Radiologie, Institut de Cancérologie de Lorraine, Vandoeuvre-Lès-Nancy, France.
Surg Radiol Anat. 2016 Mar;38(2):253-60. doi: 10.1007/s00276-015-1548-y. Epub 2015 Aug 23.
Medical anatomy instruction has been an important issue of debate for many years and imaging anatomy has become an increasingly important component in the field, the role of which has not yet been clearly defined. The aim of the paper was to assess the current deployment of medical imaging in the teaching of anatomy by means of a review of the literature.
A systematic search was performed using the electronic database PubMed, ScienceDirect and various publisher databases, with combinations of the relevant MeSH terms. A manual research was added.
In most academic curricula, imaging anatomy has been integrated as a part of anatomical education, taught using a very wide variety of strategies. Considerable variation in the time allocation, content and delivery of medical imaging in teaching human anatomy was identified. Given this considerable variation, an objective assessment remains quite difficult.
In most publications, students' perceptions regarding anatomical courses including imaging anatomy were investigated by means of questionnaires and, regardless of the method of teaching, it was globally concluded that imaging anatomy enhanced the quality and efficiency of instruction in human anatomy. More objective evaluation based on an increase in students' performance on course examinations or on specific tests performed before and after teaching sessions showed positive results in numerous cases, while mixed results were also indicated by other studies.
A relative standardization could be useful in improving the teaching of imaging anatomy, to facilitate its assessment and reinforce its effectiveness.
多年来,医学解剖学教学一直是一个重要的争论话题,而影像解剖学在该领域已成为一个日益重要的组成部分,但其作用尚未得到明确界定。本文旨在通过文献综述评估医学影像在解剖学教学中的当前应用情况。
使用电子数据库PubMed、ScienceDirect和各种出版商数据库,结合相关医学主题词进行系统检索。此外还进行了手工检索。
在大多数学术课程中,影像解剖学已作为解剖学教育的一部分被纳入,采用了非常广泛的教学策略。研究发现,在人体解剖学教学中,医学影像在时间分配、内容和授课方式上存在相当大的差异。鉴于这种显著差异,进行客观评估仍然相当困难。
在大多数出版物中,通过问卷调查研究了学生对包括影像解剖学在内的解剖学课程的看法,并且无论教学方法如何,总体上得出的结论是,影像解剖学提高了人体解剖学教学的质量和效率。基于学生课程考试成绩的提高或在教学前后进行的特定测试得出的更客观的评估在许多情况下显示出积极结果,而其他研究也表明结果不一。
相对标准化可能有助于改进影像解剖学教学,便于对其进行评估并增强其有效性。