Komzák M, Hart R, Šmíd P, Puskeiler M, Jajtner P
Ortopedicko-traumatologické oddělení, Nemocnice Znojmo.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2015;82(2):135-9.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY Growth factors produced by platelets enhance tissue healing. The aim of this study was to confirm or disprove the hypothesis that, in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, the application of platelet-rich plasma (PRP) into the tibial and femoral tunnels and in the graft enhances graft maturation and graft-bone interface healing and thus improves knee function at 3 and 12 months post-operatively in comparison with the control group. MATERIAL AND METHODS A total of 40 patient had the surgery; 20 underwent single-bundle hamstring reconstruction with PRP application (PRP group) and 20 had the same surgery without PRP addition (control group). A 5 ml amount of PRP was obtained from the patient's peripheral blood. A graft inserted in the bone tunnels was fixed with interference screws and, after intra-articular fluid aspiration, 1 ml of PRP was injected into each tunnel and 3 ml were evenly applied to the intra-articular portion of the graft. The patients were examined by MRI at 3 and 12 months after surgery. The subsidence of swelling in the tunnelsurrounding tissues was taken as a sign of graft-bone interface healing, and increased signal intensity of the graft was considered as a result of its ligamentisation. The knee functional status was evaluated at 3 and 12 post-operative months, using the scoring systems (Cincinnati score, IKDC score). RESULTS Bone swelling was found at 3 post-operative months in 18 of 20 patients in both the PRP and the control group. Graft signal intensity was increased in most patients (19 of the PRP group; 18 control patients; p = 0.949). The Cincinnati score at 3 months had an average value of 72.7 (34-100; SO, 18.7) in the PRP group and 73.4 (42-99; SO, 16.3) in the control group (p = 0.793). The functional score after 12 months improved to 97.5 (75-100; SO, 12.8) in the PRP group and to 95.1 (66-100; SO, 13.1) in the control group; there was no significant difference between the groups (p = 0.885) at either 3 or 12 months. The IKDC score showed similar results. At 12 months bone swelling was recorded in seven out of 20 patients in the PRP group and in nine patients in the control group (p = 0.751). Graft signal intensity was increased in three and four patients of the PRP and control groups, respectively (p = 0.681). There was a statistical difference between the findings at 3 and 12 months within each group, but no difference between the groups. DISCUSSION In ACL reconstruction, the process of tendon graft-to-bone healing has several stages involving inflammation, cell proliferation and graft ligamentisation. At each stage, an important role is played by growth factors produced by thrombocytes, and therefore their potential use in the treatment of injuries to ligaments and tendons has recently come into focus. A number of experimental studies dealing with the effect of platelet-rich plasma on soft tissue healing has been published. Therefore, the method of using PRP to enhance graft healing in ACL reconstruction in humans is still being studied. CONSLUSIONS The use of PRP in ACL reconstruction does not accelerate graft remodelling and bone ingrowth into the tendon. The function scoring results showed a statistically significant improvement in knee function between 3 and 12 months of followup within each group studied but revealed no difference between the groups. The hypothesis postulated above was disproved. Key words: anterior cruciate ligament, platelet-rich plasma, anatomic single-bundle reconstruction.
研究目的 血小板产生的生长因子可促进组织愈合。本研究的目的是证实或反驳以下假设:在前交叉韧带(ACL)重建中,与对照组相比,在胫骨和股骨隧道以及移植物中应用富血小板血浆(PRP)可促进移植物成熟和移植物 - 骨界面愈合,从而在术后3个月和12个月改善膝关节功能。 材料与方法 共有40例患者接受了手术;20例行单束腘绳肌重建并应用PRP(PRP组),20例接受相同手术但未添加PRP(对照组)。从患者外周血中获取5 ml PRP。插入骨隧道的移植物用干涉螺钉固定,在关节内液体抽吸后,向每个隧道注入1 ml PRP,并将3 ml均匀涂抹于移植物的关节内部分。术后3个月和12个月对患者进行MRI检查。隧道周围组织肿胀消退被视为移植物 - 骨界面愈合的标志,移植物信号强度增加被认为是其韧带化的结果。使用评分系统(辛辛那提评分、IKDC评分)在术后3个月和12个月评估膝关节功能状态。 结果 PRP组和对照组的20例患者中,术后3个月均有18例出现骨肿胀。大多数患者移植物信号强度增加(PRP组19例;对照组18例;p = 0.949)。PRP组3个月时辛辛那提评分的平均值为72.7(34 - 100;标准差,18.7),对照组为73.4(42 - 99;标准差,16.3)(p = 0.793)。12个月后,PRP组功能评分为97.5(75 - 100;标准差,12.8),对照组为95.1(66 - 100;标准差,13.1);两组在3个月和12个月时均无显著差异(p = 0.885)。IKDC评分显示了类似结果。PRP组20例患者中有7例在12个月时记录到骨肿胀,对照组有9例(p = 0.751)。PRP组和对照组分别有3例和4例患者移植物信号强度增加(p = 0.681)。每组在3个月和12个月时的结果存在统计学差异,但两组之间无差异。 讨论 在ACL重建中,肌腱移植物与骨的愈合过程有几个阶段,包括炎症、细胞增殖和移植物韧带化。在每个阶段,血小板产生的生长因子都起着重要作用,因此它们在韧带和肌腱损伤治疗中的潜在应用最近受到关注。已经发表了许多关于富血小板血浆对软组织愈合影响的实验研究。因此,在人体ACL重建中使用PRP促进移植物愈合的方法仍在研究中。 结论 在ACL重建中使用PRP不会加速移植物重塑和骨向肌腱内生长。功能评分结果显示,在每个研究组的随访3个月至12个月期间,膝关节功能有统计学意义的改善,但两组之间无差异。上述假设被证伪。 关键词:前交叉韧带;富血小板血浆;解剖单束重建