Glass Jennifer L, Sutton April, Fitzgerald Scott T
University of Texas-Austin.
University of North Carolina-Charlotte.
Soc Curr. 2015 Jun;2(2):126-143. doi: 10.1177/2329496515579764.
Research revealing associations between conservative Protestantism and lower socioeconomic status is bedeviled by questions of causal inference. Religious switching offers another way to understand the causal ordering of religious participation and demographic markers of class position. In this paper, we look at adolescents who change their religious affiliation across four waves of data from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health (Add Health) and then observe their transition to adulthood using four crucial markers - completed educational attainment, age at first marriage, age at first birth, and income at the final wave. Results show that switching out of a conservative Protestant denomination in adolescence can alter some, but not all, of the negative consequences associated with growing up in a conservative Protestant household. Specifically, family formation is delayed among switchers, but early cessation of education is not.
揭示保守新教与较低社会经济地位之间关联的研究受到因果推断问题的困扰。宗教转换为理解宗教参与和阶级地位人口统计学指标的因果顺序提供了另一种方式。在本文中,我们研究了在青少年健康全国纵向研究(Add Health)的四轮数据中改变宗教归属的青少年,然后使用四个关键指标——完成的教育程度、初婚年龄、初育年龄以及最后一轮的收入——观察他们向成年期的转变。结果表明,青少年时期脱离保守新教教派可以改变一些(但不是全部)与在保守新教家庭中成长相关的负面后果。具体而言,转换者的家庭组建会延迟,但教育过早中断的情况不会改变。