Simon Corey B, Riley Joseph L, Fillingim Roger B, Bishop Mark D, George Steven Z
Department of Physical Therapy, College of Public Health and Health Professions, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida; Pain Research & Intervention Center of Excellence, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida.
Pain Research & Intervention Center of Excellence, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida.
J Pain. 2015 Dec;16(12):1268-1279. doi: 10.1016/j.jpain.2015.08.009. Epub 2015 Sep 3.
Chronic low back pain (CLBP) is a highly prevalent and disabling musculoskeletal pain condition among older adults. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) is commonly used to treat CLBP, however response to TENS in older adults compared with younger adults is untested. In a dose-response study stratified by age, 60 participants with axial CLBP (20 young, 20 middle-aged, 20 older) received four 20-minute sessions of high-frequency high-intensity TENS over a 2- to 3-week period in a laboratory-controlled setting. Experimental measures of pain sensitivity (mechanical pressure pain detection threshold) and central pain excitability (phasic heat temporal summation and heat aftersensations) were assessed before and after TENS. Episodic or immediate axial CLBP relief was assessed after TENS via measures of resting pain, movement-evoked-pain, and self-reported disability. Cumulative or prolonged axial CLBP relief was assessed by comparing daily pain reports across sessions. Independent of age, individuals experienced episodic increase in the pressure pain detection threshold and reduction in aftersensation after TENS application. Similarly, all groups, on average, experienced episodic axial CLBP relief via improved resting pain, movement-evoked pain, and disability report. Under this design, no cumulative effect was observed as daily pain did not improve for any age group across the 4 sessions. However, older adults received higher TENS amplitude across all sessions to achieve TENS responses similar to those in younger adults. These findings suggest that older adults experience similar episodic axial CLBP relief to that of younger individuals after high-frequency, high-intensity TENS when higher dose parameters are used.
This study examined age group differences in experimental and axial CLBP response to TENS, delivered under the current recommended parameters of strong, but tolerable amplitude. Older adults had comparable TENS response although at higher TENS amplitude than younger adults, which may have important mechanistic and clinical implications.
慢性下腰痛(CLBP)是老年人中一种高度普遍且致残的肌肉骨骼疼痛病症。经皮电刺激神经疗法(TENS)常用于治疗CLBP,然而与年轻人相比,老年人对TENS的反应尚未得到测试。在一项按年龄分层的剂量反应研究中,60名患有轴性CLBP的参与者(20名年轻人、20名中年人、20名老年人)在实验室控制的环境中,于2至3周内接受了4次每次20分钟的高频高强度TENS治疗。在TENS治疗前后评估疼痛敏感性(机械压力疼痛检测阈值)和中枢疼痛兴奋性(相位性热时间总和及热后感觉)的实验指标。通过静息痛、运动诱发痛和自我报告的残疾程度测量,在TENS治疗后评估发作性或即时性轴性CLBP缓解情况。通过比较各疗程的每日疼痛报告来评估累积性或持续性轴性CLBP缓解情况。与年龄无关,个体在应用TENS后压力疼痛检测阈值出现发作性升高,后感觉减轻。同样,所有组平均通过改善静息痛、运动诱发痛和残疾报告,经历了发作性轴性CLBP缓解。在这种设计下,未观察到累积效应,因为在4个疗程中任何年龄组的每日疼痛均未改善。然而,老年人在所有疗程中接受了更高的TENS振幅,以实现与年轻人相似的TENS反应。这些发现表明,当使用更高剂量参数时,老年人在高频、高强度TENS治疗后经历的发作性轴性CLBP缓解与年轻人相似。
本研究在当前推荐的强但可耐受的振幅参数下,检查了不同年龄组对TENS的实验性和轴性CLBP反应差异。老年人的TENS反应相当,尽管其TENS振幅高于年轻人,这可能具有重要的机制和临床意义。