From the Department of Radiology and Research Institute of Radiology (N.S., Seong H. Park, S.Y.K., H.K.H.), Department of Gastroenterology (K.J.K., S.K.Y., B.D.Y., Sang H. Park), and Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (S.B.), University of Ulsan College of Medicine, Asan Medical Center, 88 Olympic-ro 43-gil, Songpa-gu, Seoul, South Korea; Department of Radiology, Hanyang University Medical Center, Seoul, South Korea (B.K.K.); Department of Radiology, Inje University College of Medicine, Busan, South Korea (Y.L.); and Biostatistics Collaboration Unit, Gangnam Medical Research Center, Yonsei University College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea (K.H.).
Radiology. 2016 Mar;278(3):762-72. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2015150809. Epub 2015 Sep 8.
To determine whether magnetic resonance (MR) enterography performed with diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI) without intravenous contrast material is noninferior to contrast material-enhanced (CE) MR enterography for the evaluation of small-bowel inflammation in Crohn disease.
Institutional review board approval and informed consent were obtained for this prospective noninferiority study. Fifty consecutive adults suspected of having Crohn disease underwent clinical assessment, MR enterography, and ileocolonoscopy within 1 week. MR enterography included conventional imaging and DWI (b = 900 sec/mm(2)). In 44 patients with Crohn disease, 171 small-bowel segments that were generally well distended and showed a wide range of findings, from normalcy to severe inflammation (34 men, 10 women; mean age ± standard deviation, 26.9 years ± 6.1), were selected for analysis. Image sets consisting of (a) T2-weighted sequences with DWI and (b) T2-weighted sequences with CE T1-weighted sequences were reviewed by using a crossover design with blinding and randomization. Statistical analyses included noninferiority testing regarding proportional agreement between DWI and CE MR enterography for the identification of bowel inflammation with a noninferiority margin of 80%, correlation between DWI and CE MR enterography scores of bowel inflammation severity, and comparison of accuracy between DWI and CE MR enterography for the diagnosis of terminal ileal inflammation by using endoscopic findings as the reference standard.
The agreement between DWI and CE MR enterography for the identification of bowel inflammation was 91.8% (157 of 171 segments; one-sided 95% confidence interval: ≥88.4%). The correlation coefficient between DWI and CE MR enterography scores was 0.937 (P < .001). DWI and CE MR enterography did not differ significantly regarding the sensitivity and specificity for the diagnosis of terminal ileal inflammation (P > .999). DWI and CE MR enterography concurred in the diagnosis of penetrating complications in five of eight segments.
DWI MR enterography was noninferior to CE MR enterography for the evaluation of inflammation in Crohn disease in generally well-distended small bowel, except for the diagnosis of penetration.
确定磁共振(MR)小肠造影术(MR enterography)是否可在不使用静脉对比剂的情况下,利用弥散加权成像(diffusion-weighted imaging,DWI)来评估克罗恩病(Crohn disease)的小肠炎症,且效果不劣于对比增强 MR 小肠造影术(contrast material-enhanced MR enterography,CE MR enterography)。
本前瞻性非劣效性研究获得了机构审查委员会(institutional review board)的批准和患者的知情同意。50 例连续疑似患有克罗恩病的成人患者在 1 周内接受了临床评估、MR 小肠造影术和结肠镜检查。MR 小肠造影术包括常规成像和 DWI(b 值=900 sec/mm²)。在 44 例克罗恩病患者中,有 171 段小肠通常处于良好扩张状态,表现出广泛的病变,从正常到严重炎症(34 名男性,10 名女性;平均年龄±标准差,26.9 岁±6.1 岁),这些段小肠被选中进行分析。采用双盲和随机设计,对包含(a)DWI 的 T2 加权序列和(b)CE T1 加权序列的 T2 加权序列的图像集进行分析。统计分析包括评估 DWI 与 CE MR 小肠造影术在识别肠炎症方面的比例一致性(非劣效性界值为 80%)、肠炎症严重程度的 DWI 与 CE MR 小肠造影术评分之间的相关性,以及比较 DWI 与 CE MR 小肠造影术在根据内镜检查结果作为参考标准时,对末端回肠炎的诊断准确性。
DWI 与 CE MR 小肠造影术在识别肠炎症方面的一致性为 91.8%(171 段中的 157 段;单侧 95%置信区间:≥88.4%)。DWI 与 CE MR 小肠造影术评分之间的相关系数为 0.937(P<.001)。在诊断末端回肠炎的敏感性和特异性方面,DWI 与 CE MR 小肠造影术之间无显著差异(P>.999)。DWI 与 CE MR 小肠造影术在诊断 8 段中的 5 段穿透性并发症时,诊断结果一致。
在通常扩张良好的小肠中,DWI 磁共振小肠造影术在评估克罗恩病的炎症方面不劣于 CE MR 小肠造影术,但其对穿透性的诊断效果不如后者。