Deakin Health Economics, Deakin University, and Obesity and Population Health, Baker IDI Heart and Diabetes Institute, Melbourne, VIC, Australia.
Clinical Epidemiology Unit, Department of Medicine, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol. 2015 Nov;3(11):855-65. doi: 10.1016/S2213-8587(15)00290-9. Epub 2015 Sep 17.
Bariatric surgery prevents and induces remission of type 2 diabetes in many patients. The effect of preoperative glucose status on long-term health-care costs is unknown. We aimed to assess health-care costs over 15 years for patients with obesity treated conventionally or with bariatric surgery and who had either euglycaemia, prediabetes, or type 2 diabetes before intervention.
The Swedish Obese Subjects (SOS) study is a prospective study of adults who had bariatric surgery and contemporaneously matched controls who were treated conventionally (age 37-60 years; BMI of ≥34 in men and ≥38 in women) recruited from 25 Swedish surgical departments and 480 primary health-care centres. Exclusion criteria were identical for both study groups, and were previous gastric or bariatric surgery, recent malignancy or myocardial infarction, selected psychiatric disorders, and other contraindicating disorders to bariatric surgery. Conventional treatment ranged from no treatment to lifestyle intervention and behaviour modification. In this study, we retrieved prescription drug costs for the patients in the SOS study via questionnaires and the nationwide Swedish Prescribed Drug Register. We retrieved data for inpatient and outpatient visits from the Swedish National Patient Register. We followed up the sample linked to register data for up to 15 years. We adjusted mean differences for baseline characteristics. Analyses were by intention to treat. The SOS study is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT01479452.
Between Sept 1, 1987, and Jan 31, 2001, 2010 adults who had bariatric surgery and 2037 who were treated conventionally were enrolled into the SOS study. In this study, we followed up 4030 patients (2836 who were euglycaemic; 591 who had prediabetes; 603 who had diabetes). Drug costs did not differ between the surgery and conventional treatment groups in the euglycaemic subgroup (surgery US$10,511 vs conventional treatment $10,680; adjusted mean difference -$225 [95% CI -2080 to 1631]; p=0·812), but were lower in the surgery group in the prediabetes ($10,194 vs $13,186; -$3329 [-5722 to -937]; p=0·007) and diabetes ($14,346 vs $19,511; -$5487 [-7925 to -3049]; p<0·0001) subgroups than in the conventional treatment group. Compared with the conventional treatment group, we noted greater inpatient costs in the surgery group for the euglycaemic ($51,225 vs $25,313; $22,931 [19,001-26,861]; p<0·0001), prediabetes ($58,699 vs $32,861; $27,152 [18,736-35,568]; p<0·0001), and diabetes ($61,569 vs $47,569; 18,697 [9992-27,402]; p<0·0001) subgroups. We noted no differences in outpatient costs. Total health-care costs were higher in the surgery group in the euglycaemic ($71,059 vs $45,542; $22,390 [17,358-27,423]; p<0·0001) and prediabetes ($78,151 vs $54,864; $26,292 [16,738-35,845]; p<0·0001) subgroups than in the conventional treatment group, whereas we detected no difference between treatment groups in patients with diabetes ($88,572 vs $79,967; $9081 [-1419 to 19,581]; p=0·090).
Total health-care costs were higher for patients with euglycaemia or prediabetes in the surgery group than in the conventional treatment group, but we detected no difference between the surgery and conventional treatment groups for patients with diabetes. Long-term health-care cost results support prioritisation of patients with obesity and type 2 diabetes for bariatric surgery.
AFA Försäkring and Swedish Scientific Research Council.
减重手术可预防和诱导 2 型糖尿病缓解,在许多患者中都有此效果。术前血糖状态对长期医疗保健成本的影响尚不清楚。我们旨在评估接受肥胖治疗的患者在接受常规治疗或接受减重手术的情况下,在干预前血糖水平正常、处于糖尿病前期或患有 2 型糖尿病时,在 15 年内的医疗保健费用。
瑞典肥胖患者(SOS)研究是一项前瞻性研究,纳入了接受减重手术的成年人和同期接受常规治疗的匹配对照者(年龄 37-60 岁;男性 BMI≥34,女性 BMI≥38),他们来自 25 个瑞典外科科室和 480 个初级保健中心。两组的排除标准相同,包括既往胃或减重手术、近期恶性肿瘤或心肌梗死、选择的精神障碍以及其他对减重手术有禁忌的疾病。常规治疗范围从无治疗到生活方式干预和行为改变。在这项研究中,我们通过问卷调查和全国瑞典处方药物登记处检索了 SOS 研究中患者的处方药费用。我们从瑞典国家患者登记处检索了住院和门诊就诊的数据。我们对与登记数据相关联的样本进行了长达 15 年的随访。我们对基线特征进行了调整均值差异分析。分析按意向治疗进行。SOS 研究在 ClinicalTrials.gov 注册,编号为 NCT01479452。
在 1987 年 9 月 1 日至 2001 年 1 月 31 日期间,有 2010 名接受减重手术的成年人和 2037 名接受常规治疗的成年人被纳入 SOS 研究。在这项研究中,我们对 4030 名患者进行了随访(2836 名血糖正常;591 名处于糖尿病前期;603 名患有糖尿病)。在血糖正常亚组中,手术组和常规治疗组的药物费用没有差异(手术组 10511 美元,常规治疗组 10680 美元;调整后的平均差值 -225 [95%CI-2080 至 1631];p=0.812),但在糖尿病前期(手术组 10194 美元,常规治疗组 13186 美元;-3329 [-5722 至-937];p=0.007)和糖尿病(手术组 14346 美元,常规治疗组 19511 美元;-5487 [-7925 至-3049];p<0.0001)亚组中,手术组的药物费用低于常规治疗组。与常规治疗组相比,我们发现手术组的血糖正常亚组的住院费用更高(手术组 51225 美元,常规治疗组 25313 美元;51225-25313=25912 美元;22931 [19001-26861];p<0.0001),糖尿病前期亚组(手术组 58699 美元,常规治疗组 32861 美元;58699-32861=25838 美元;27152 [18736-35868];p<0.0001)和糖尿病亚组(手术组 61569 美元,常规治疗组 47569 美元;61569-47569=14000 美元;18697 [9992-27402];p<0.0001)。我们没有发现门诊费用的差异。在血糖正常(手术组 71059 美元,常规治疗组 45542 美元;71059-45542=25517 美元;22390 [17358-27423];p<0.0001)和糖尿病前期亚组(手术组 78151 美元,常规治疗组 54864 美元;78151-54864=23287 美元;26292 [16738-35845];p<0.0001)中,手术组的总医疗保健费用高于常规治疗组,而在糖尿病组中,两组之间没有差异(手术组 88572 美元,常规治疗组 79967 美元;88572-79967=8605 美元;9081 [-1419 至 19581];p=0.090)。
对于血糖正常或糖尿病前期的患者,手术组的总医疗保健费用高于常规治疗组,但我们没有发现手术组和常规治疗组的糖尿病患者之间存在差异。长期医疗保健成本结果支持将肥胖和 2 型糖尿病患者列为减重手术的优先对象。
AFA Försäkring 和瑞典科学研究委员会。