Crétual A
M2S lab (Mouvement Sport Santé), University Rennes 2 - ENS Rennes - UEB, avenue Robert-Schuman, campus de Ker Lann, 35170 Bruz, France; MimeTIC team, INRIA Rennes, campus universitaire de Beaulieu, 35042 Rennes, France.
Neurophysiol Clin. 2015 Nov;45(4-5):285-95. doi: 10.1016/j.neucli.2015.07.004. Epub 2015 Sep 18.
In 1995, David Winter concluded that postural analysis of upright stance was often restricted to studying the trajectory of the center of pressure (CoP). However, postural control means regulation of the center of mass (CoM) with respect to CoP. As CoM is only accessible by using a biomechanical model of the human body, the present article proposes to determine which models are actually used in postural analysis, twenty years after Winter's observation. To do so, a selection of 252 representative articles dealing with upright posture and published during the four last years has been checked. It appears that the CoP model largely remains the most common one (accounting for nearly two thirds of the selection). Other models, CoP/CoM and segmental models (with one, two or more segments) are much less used. The choice of the model does not appear to be guided by the population studied. Conversely, while some confusion remains between postural control and the associated concepts of stability or strategy, this choice is better justified for real methodological concerns when dealing with such high-level parameters. Finally, the computation of the CoM continues to be a limitation in achieving a more complete postural analysis. This unfortunately implies that the model is chosen for technological reasons in many cases (choice being a euphemism here). Some effort still has to be made so that bioengineering developments allow us to go beyond this limit.
1995年,大卫·温特得出结论,直立姿势的姿势分析通常局限于研究压力中心(CoP)的轨迹。然而,姿势控制意味着相对于CoP对质心(CoM)进行调节。由于CoM只能通过使用人体生物力学模型来获取,本文建议在温特的观察过去二十年后,确定在姿势分析中实际使用的是哪些模型。为此,对过去四年发表的252篇关于直立姿势的代表性文章进行了筛选。结果表明,CoP模型在很大程度上仍然是最常用的模型(占所选文章的近三分之二)。其他模型,如CoP/CoM模型和节段模型(一个、两个或更多节段)的使用则少得多。模型的选择似乎不受所研究人群的指导。相反,虽然姿势控制与稳定性或策略等相关概念之间仍存在一些混淆,但在处理此类高级参数时,这种选择从实际方法学角度来看更有依据。最后,CoM的计算仍然是实现更完整姿势分析的一个限制。不幸的是,这意味着在许多情况下,模型的选择是出于技术原因(这里“选择”是一种委婉说法)。仍需做出一些努力,以便生物工程的发展能让我们突破这一限制。