Vinci Stefano, Smith Anne, Ranelli Sonia
School of Physiotherapy and Exercise Science, Curtin University, GPO Box U1987, Perth, WA 6845, Australia. Tel +61 8 9266 1221, fax +61 8 9266 3699.
Med Probl Perform Art. 2015 Sep;30(3):143-51. doi: 10.21091/mppa.2015.3028.
Music research has investigated the prevalence of playing-related musculoskeletal problems in adults and children, but the prevalence in adolescents has not been established. String instrumentalists report high problem rates, though it is unclear whether rates vary between upper and lower strings in adolescent instrumentalists. Further, there is limited evidence for the association between physical characteristics and playing problems in this group of musicians.
Seventy-six adolescent string musicians from the West Australian Youth Orchestras were surveyed. Their experience of playing problems, both symptoms (PRMS) and disorders (PRMD), within the last month and measurements of body mass index, hand span, and joint mobility (Beighton scale) were obtained. Prevalence rates were calculated and compared between upper and lower string instrumentalists using a chi-squared test. Logistic regression examined the association of physical measures with playing problems, adjusting for confounding factors.
Within the last month, 73.5% participants reported experiencing a PRMS and 26.5percnt; reported experiencing a PRMD. There was no significant difference between the problem rates in upper and lower string instrumentalists. After adjusting for potential confounders, an increasing count of hypermobile joints remained significantly associated with problems (OR 1.76, CI 1.02 to 3.04, p=0.042).
This study found playing problems are common in adolescent string instrumentalists, though rates did not differ between upper and lower string players. Joint hypermobility was associated with playing-related problems in adolescent musicians. Early identification of problems in this group of maturing musicians may help prevent disabling disorders and maximize performance.
音乐研究已经调查了成人和儿童中与演奏相关的肌肉骨骼问题的患病率,但青少年中的患病率尚未确定。弦乐器演奏者报告的问题发生率较高,不过尚不清楚青少年乐器演奏者中高音弦和低音弦的问题发生率是否存在差异。此外,在这组音乐家中,身体特征与演奏问题之间关联的证据有限。
对来自西澳大利亚青年管弦乐团的76名青少年弦乐器演奏者进行了调查。获取了他们在过去一个月内的演奏问题经历,包括症状(PRMS)和疾病(PRMD),以及体重指数、手跨度和关节活动度(Beighton量表)的测量值。使用卡方检验计算患病率并比较高音弦和低音弦乐器演奏者之间的差异。逻辑回归分析了身体测量指标与演奏问题之间的关联,并对混杂因素进行了调整。
在过去一个月内,73.5%的参与者报告经历过PRMS,26.5%的参与者报告经历过PRMD。高音弦和低音弦乐器演奏者的问题发生率之间没有显著差异。在对潜在混杂因素进行调整后,关节活动过度的数量增加仍与问题显著相关(OR 1.76,CI 1.02至3.04,p = 0.042)。
本研究发现演奏问题在青少年弦乐器演奏者中很常见,尽管高音弦和低音弦演奏者的发生率没有差异。关节活动过度与青少年音乐家的演奏相关问题有关。尽早识别这组成熟音乐家中的问题可能有助于预防致残性疾病并最大限度地提高演奏水平。