Yamahata Hitoshi, Yamaguchi Satoshi, Takayasu Masakazu, Takasaki Koji, Osuka Koji, Aoyama Masahiro, Yasuda Muneyoshi, Tokimura Hiroshi, Kurisu Kaoru, Arita Kazunori
Department of Neurosurgery, Graduate School of Medical and Dental Sciences, Kagoshima University, Kagoshima, Japan.
Department of Neurosurgery, Hiroshima University Graduate School of Biomedical Sciences, Hiroshima, Japan.
World Neurosurg. 2016 Mar;87:1-7. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2015.09.022. Epub 2015 Sep 25.
The resection of foramen magnum meningiomas (FMMs) presents neurosurgical challenges. We propose a simple classification of the tumor location and the operating space created by the tumor to help treatment planning.
We retrospectively analyzed 16 FMMs and divided them into 3 groups based on the tumor location--clival, foraminal, and atlantal tumors. The distance between the condyle and the neuraxis at the level of the foramen magnum was measured and defined as the available operative space (AOS). We also reviewed intraoperative video recordings to assess the surgical exposure of the tumor by the space created by the FMM and compared it with the AOS.
There were 4 clival, 8 foraminal, and 4 atlantal tumors. The AOS of the clival tumors was 10 mm ± 1.7, the AOS of the foraminal tumors was 18 mm ± 3.7, and the AOS of the atlantal tumors was 12 mm ± 2.1. All foraminal and atlantal tumors could be detached without a brain retractor. Because a major portion of the clival tumors was covered by the spinomedullary junction, a brain spatula was needed to obtain the required surgical space. The difference in AOS between clival and foraminal/atlantal tumors was statistically significant (P = 0.044). Although 4 patients experienced postoperative complications, the average postoperative Karnofsky performance scale score improved. The surgical complication rate was significantly lower in foraminal and atlantal FMMs than in clival FMMs (P = 0.027).
The simple classification of the tumor location helped to assess surgical difficulties. Knowledge of the space created by the FMMs between the condyle and the neuraxis is useful for planning the approach strategy, especially for estimating the available working space without resection of the occipital condyle.
枕骨大孔脑膜瘤(FMMs)的切除面临神经外科挑战。我们提出一种简单的肿瘤位置及肿瘤所形成手术空间的分类方法,以辅助治疗规划。
我们回顾性分析了16例FMMs,并根据肿瘤位置将其分为3组——斜坡肿瘤、孔区肿瘤和寰椎肿瘤。测量枕骨大孔水平髁突与神经轴之间的距离,并将其定义为可用手术空间(AOS)。我们还回顾了术中录像,以评估FMMs所形成空间对肿瘤的手术显露情况,并将其与AOS进行比较。
有4例斜坡肿瘤、8例孔区肿瘤和4例寰椎肿瘤。斜坡肿瘤的AOS为10 mm±1.7,孔区肿瘤的AOS为18 mm±3.7,寰椎肿瘤的AOS为12 mm±2.1。所有孔区和寰椎肿瘤均可在不使用脑牵开器的情况下分离。由于斜坡肿瘤的大部分被脊髓延髓交界处覆盖,需要使用脑压板来获得所需的手术空间。斜坡肿瘤与孔区/寰椎肿瘤的AOS差异具有统计学意义(P = 0.044)。虽然4例患者出现术后并发症,但术后卡氏功能状态评分平均有所提高。孔区和寰椎FMMs的手术并发症发生率显著低于斜坡FMMs(P = 0.027)。
肿瘤位置的简单分类有助于评估手术难度。了解FMMs在髁突与神经轴之间所形成的空间,对于规划手术入路策略很有用,尤其是在不切除枕髁的情况下估计可用工作空间。