Piazza Veronica, Gambardella Chiara, Canepa Sara, Costa Elisa, Faimali Marco, Garaventa Francesca
Institute of Marine Science (ISMAR), CNR, via De Marini 6, 16149 Genoa, Italy.
Institute of Marine Science (ISMAR), CNR, via De Marini 6, 16149 Genoa, Italy.
Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. 2016 Jan;123:8-17. doi: 10.1016/j.ecoenv.2015.09.023. Epub 2015 Sep 26.
The official protocol of an ecotoxicological assay employing larvae of the crustacean Amphibalanus amphitrite as a model organism has recently been published by the Italian regulatory authority UNICHIM. Such assay is now one of the applicable tests for water quality assessment under Italian law. While specific temperature and salinity values are recommended by ecotoxicology bioassay protocols for test set up, little information is available on response changes in case of parameter variations. In particular, information is totally lacking for this innovative model organism. Under the standard test protocol, 20°C and 37‰ temperature and salinity, respectively, are required to be set in A. amphitrite bioassay. In order to evaluate the environmental relevance of the test, laboratory experiments simulating the effect on larval responses due to variations of temperature and salinity expected in field collected samples were carried out. The effect of temperature and salinity changes on different end-points, involving increasing sensitivity levels, has been investigated, with and without the presence of cadmium nitrate, Cd(NO3)2, as a reference toxicant, to determine the possible interactions between pollutants and environmental parameters fluctuations. Three end-points - mortality, immobilization, and swimming speed alteration - were measured in order to evaluate the impact of a wide range of temperature (5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 35, 40°C) and salinity values (10, 20, 30, 37, 40, 50, 60, 70‰) on response variation after 24 and 48h of exposure. For each parameter, a Non-Effect Range (NER) - namely the limit values within which no effect related to environmental parameter changes is observed - has been defined. For both parameters, NER resulted to be wider for the less sensitive end-points - such as mortality and immobilization - and for shorter exposure time (24h). Later, the same end-points have been evaluated by exposing the same organisms to a reference toxic compound, Cd(NO3)2 (0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.8, 1.6, 3.2mg/L), within the detected NER both for temperature and salinity. LC50 and EC50 values have been calculated for each end-point after 24 and 48h. Cadmium toxicity was shown to decrease at higher salinity values and increase at higher temperatures. Obtained results offer a better bioassay characterization, and the possibility of a more realistic estimation of ecotoxicological assessments performed on field collected samples. Further studies are needed, especially to investigate the effects of simultaneous salinity and temperature changes on end-points.
意大利监管机构UNICHIM最近发布了一份生态毒理学检测的官方方案,该方案采用甲壳类动物双齿围沙蚕的幼虫作为模式生物。这种检测现在是意大利法律规定的水质评估适用测试之一。虽然生态毒理学生物检测方案推荐了用于测试设置的特定温度和盐度值,但关于参数变化时响应变化的信息却很少。特别是,对于这种创新的模式生物,完全缺乏相关信息。在标准测试方案中,双齿围沙蚕生物检测要求分别设置20°C和37‰的温度和盐度。为了评估该测试与环境的相关性,进行了实验室实验,模拟野外采集样本中预期的温度和盐度变化对幼虫反应的影响。研究了温度和盐度变化对不同终点的影响,这些终点涉及不同的敏感水平,实验中添加和不添加硝酸镉Cd(NO₃)₂作为参考毒物,以确定污染物与环境参数波动之间可能的相互作用。测量了三个终点——死亡率、固定化和游泳速度改变——以评估在暴露24小时和48小时后,广泛的温度(5、10、15、20、25、30、35、40°C)和盐度值(10、20、30、37、40、50、60、70‰)对反应变化的影响。对于每个参数,定义了一个无效应范围(NER)——即未观察到与环境参数变化相关效应的极限值。对于这两个参数,在较不敏感的终点(如死亡率和固定化)以及较短的暴露时间(24小时)下,NER更宽。随后,通过将相同的生物暴露于参考有毒化合物Cd(NO₃)₂(0、0.2、0.4、0.8、1.6、3.2mg/L),在检测到的温度和盐度的NER范围内,对相同的终点进行了评估。计算了24小时和48小时后每个终点的LC50和EC50值。结果表明,镉毒性在较高盐度值下降低,在较高温度下增加。获得的结果提供了更好的生物检测特征,以及对野外采集样本进行更实际的生态毒理学评估的可能性。还需要进一步的研究,特别是要研究盐度和温度同时变化对终点的影响。