Havrda Matyáš
Early Sci Med. 2015;20(3):265-87. doi: 10.1163/15733823-00203p03.
This paper concerns the lost treatise On Demonstration (DD) written by Galen of Pergamum (129 - ca. 215 AD). Its aim is to reconstruct the purpose of this treatise, especially the question of how, in Galen's view, it was supposed to be useful for doctors. While showing that the methods described in DD were designed to settle disagreements among doctors, the paper argues that the choice of topics discussed there was partly determined by Galen's worry about a mode of reasoning, exemplified by scepticism, that leads people into believing that plain phenomena, such as those on which both medical practice and theory are based, do not exist.
本文关注的是由佩加蒙的盖伦(公元129年 - 约公元215年)所著的失传论文《论论证》(DD)。其目的是重构该论文的目的,尤其是在盖伦看来,它应如何对医生有用的问题。在表明《论论证》中所描述的方法旨在解决医生之间的分歧的同时,本文认为其中所讨论主题的选择部分是由盖伦对一种推理模式的担忧所决定的,怀疑论就是这种推理模式的例证,它使人们相信一些明显的现象不存在,比如那些医学实践和理论所基于的现象。