Swain Matthew J, Kharrazi Hadi
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, United States.
Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Center for Population Health Information Technology, Baltimore, United States.
Int J Med Inform. 2015 Dec;84(12):1048-56. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2015.09.003. Epub 2015 Sep 14.
Unplanned 30-day hospital readmission account for roughly $17 billion in annual Medicare spending. Many factors contribute to unplanned hospital readmissions and multiple models have been developed over the years to predict them. Most researchers have used insurance claims or administrative data to train and operationalize their Readmission Risk Prediction Models (RRPMs). Some RRPM developers have also used electronic health records data; however, using health informatics exchange data has been uncommon among such predictive models and can be beneficial in its ability to provide real-time alerts to providers at the point of care.
We conducted a semi-systematic review of readmission predictive factors published prior to March 2013. Then, we extracted and merged all significant variables listed in those articles for RRPMs. Finally, we matched these variables with common HL7 messages transmitted by a sample of health information exchange organizations (HIO).
The semi-systematic review resulted in identification of 32 articles and 297 predictive variables. The mapping of these variables with common HL7 segments resulted in an 89.2% total coverage, with the DG1 (diagnosis) segment having the highest coverage of 39.4%. The PID (patient identification) and OBX (observation results) segments cover 13.9% and 9.1% of the variables. Evaluating the same coverage in three sample HIOs showed data incompleteness.
HIOs can utilize HL7 messages to develop unique RRPMs for their stakeholders; however, data completeness of exchanged messages should meet certain thresholds. If data quality standards are met by stakeholders, HIOs would be able to provide real-time RRPMs that not only predict intra-hospital readmissions but also inter-hospital cases.
A RRPM derived using HIO data exchanged through may prove to be a useful method to prevent unplanned hospital readmissions. In order for the RRPM derived from HIO data to be effective, hospitals must actively exchange clinical information through the HIO and develop actionable methods that integrate into the workflow of providers to ensure that patients at high-risk for readmission receive the care they need.
计划外30天内再次入院的情况每年在医疗保险支出中约占170亿美元。导致计划外再次入院的因素众多,多年来已开发出多种模型来预测此类情况。大多数研究人员使用保险理赔或行政数据来训练和实施他们的再入院风险预测模型(RRPM)。一些RRPM开发者也使用了电子健康记录数据;然而,在这类预测模型中使用健康信息交换数据并不常见,而它在能够在护理点向提供者提供实时警报方面可能具有优势。
我们对2013年3月之前发表的再入院预测因素进行了半系统综述。然后,我们提取并合并了那些文章中列出的RRPM的所有重要变量。最后,我们将这些变量与健康信息交换组织(HIO)样本传输的常见HL7消息进行匹配。
半系统综述识别出32篇文章和297个预测变量。这些变量与常见HL7段的映射导致总覆盖率达到89.2%,其中DG1(诊断)段的覆盖率最高,为39.4%。PID(患者识别)和OBX(观察结果)段分别覆盖变量的13.9%和9.1%。在三个样本HIO中评估相同的覆盖率显示数据不完整。
HIO可以利用HL7消息为其利益相关者开发独特的RRPM;然而,交换消息的数据完整性应达到一定阈值。如果利益相关者满足数据质量标准,HIO将能够提供不仅能预测医院内再入院情况,还能预测医院间情况的实时RRPM。
通过HIO交换的数据得出的RRPM可能是预防计划外医院再入院的一种有用方法。为了使从HIO数据得出的RRPM有效,医院必须通过HIO积极交换临床信息,并开发可融入提供者工作流程的可操作方法,以确保有再入院高风险的患者获得所需护理。