Bindroo Sandiya, Saraf Rakesh
1 Providence Hospital & Medical Center, Southfield, Michigan, USA.
2 Government Medical College, Jammu, India.
Int Surg. 2015 Jun;100(6):1026-32. doi: 10.9738/INTSURG-D-14-00212.1.
Surgical audit is a systematic, critical analysis of the quality of surgical care that is reviewed by peers against explicit criteria or recognized standards. It is used to improve surgical practice with the ultimate goal of improving patient care. As the pattern of surgical care is different in the developing world, we analyzed mortalities in a referral medical institute of India to suggest interventions for improvement. An analysis of total admissions, different surgeries, and mortalities over 1 year in an urban referral medical institute of northern India was performed, followed by "peer review" of the mortalities. Mortality rates as outcomes and classification was done to provide comparative results. Of 10,005 surgical patients, 337 (male = 221, female = 116) deaths were reported over 1 year. The overall mortality rate was 3.36%, while mortality in operative cases was 1.76%. Total deaths were classified into (1) Viable: 153 (45%), (2) Nonviable: 174 (52%), and (3) Indeterminate: 10 (3%). Exclusion of the nonviable group reduced the mortality rate from 3.36% to 1.62%. Trauma was the major cause of mortality (n = 235; 70%) as compared to other surgical patients (n = 102; 30%). Increased mortality was also associated with emergency procedures (3.66%) as compared to elective surgeries (0.34%). In conclusion, audit of mortality and morbidity helps in initiating and implementing preventive strategies to improve surgical practice and patient care, and to reduce mortality rates. The mortality and morbidity forum is an important educational activity. It should be considered a mandatory activity in all postgraduate training programs.
手术审计是对手术治疗质量进行的系统、批判性分析,由同行根据明确的标准或公认的规范进行审查。其目的是改善手术操作,最终目标是提高患者护理水平。由于发展中国家的手术治疗模式有所不同,我们分析了印度一家转诊医疗机构的死亡率,以提出改进措施。我们对印度北部一家城市转诊医疗机构1年期间的总入院人数、不同手术及死亡率进行了分析,随后对死亡率进行了“同行评审”。以死亡率作为结果并进行分类,以提供比较结果。在10005例手术患者中,1年期间报告了337例死亡(男性221例,女性116例)。总体死亡率为3.36%,而手术病例的死亡率为1.76%。总死亡病例分为:(1)可避免的:153例(45%),(2)不可避免的:174例(52%),(3)不确定的:10例(3%)。排除不可避免组后,死亡率从3.36%降至1.62%。与其他手术患者(102例,占30%)相比,创伤是主要的死亡原因(235例,占70%)。与择期手术(0.34%)相比,急诊手术的死亡率也更高(3.66%)。总之,对死亡率和发病率的审计有助于启动和实施预防策略,以改善手术操作和患者护理,并降低死亡率。死亡率和发病率研讨会是一项重要的教育活动。应将其视为所有研究生培训项目中的一项强制性活动。