Najarian J S, Kaufman D B, Fryd D S, McHugh L, Mauer S M, Ramsay R C, Kennedy W R, Navarro X, Goetz F C, Sutherland D E
Department of Surgery, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis 55455.
Transplantation. 1989 Jan;47(1):106-13. doi: 10.1097/00007890-198901000-00024.
Between December 1966 and April 1978, 265 uremic patients with type I diabetes received primary renal allografts at the University of Minnesota. One hundred of the diabetic patients were alive with a functioning graft 10 years after transplantation. The actual 10-year patient and primary graft functional survival rates overall were 40% and 32%, respectively. For recipients of HLA-identical sibling (n = 45), mismatched living-related (n = 121), and cadaver donor grafts (n = 99), the actual 10-year patient survival rates were 64%, 33%, and 36%, respectively, and the actual 10-year graft functional survival rates were 62%, 28%, and 22%, respectively. The differences in patient and graft survival rates between HLA-identical graft recipients and recipients of mismatched related and cadaver grafts were significant (P less than 0.001). Of the 100 patients who survived into a second decade, at 15 years posttransplant 51% were alive, and 41% had functioning grafts. For recipients of HLA-identical sibling, mismatched living-related donor grafts, and cadaver donor grafts who survived 10 years, 47%, 57%, and 43%, respectively, were alive at 15 years, and 31%, 45%, and 43%, respectively, had functioning grafts. For recipients who made it to the second decade, patient and primary graft survival rates thereafter were not statistically different by donor source. Twenty-three patients died in the second decade after transplantation, 10 of cardiovascular disease. Twenty-five patients lost graft function in the second decade, 19 from death with a functioning graft. In regard to diabetic complications, recurrence of diabetic nephropathy was common, but only two patients lost graft function solely for this reason. In 21 patients (42 eyes) followed prospectively for 10 years, visual acuity deteriorated in 26%, was stable in 64%, and improved in 10% of eyes. Neurophysiological test results indicated that correction of uremia does not stop the progression of diabetic neuropathy in recipients of kidney transplants alone. Even without cyclosporine, nearly two-thirds of recipients of HLA-identical kidney grafts, more than one-quarter of recipients of mismatched living-related donor grafts, and more than one-fifth receiving cadaver grafts enjoyed an extension of life for more than 10 years.
1966年12月至1978年4月期间,265例I型糖尿病尿毒症患者在明尼苏达大学接受了首次肾脏同种异体移植。100例糖尿病患者在移植后10年仍存活且移植肾功能良好。实际的10年患者和首次移植功能存活率总体分别为40%和32%。对于HLA相同的同胞供者移植受者(n = 45)、配型不合的亲属供者移植受者(n = 121)和尸体供者移植受者(n = 99),实际的10年患者存活率分别为64%、33%和36%,实际的10年移植功能存活率分别为62%、28%和22%。HLA相同移植受者与配型不合的亲属和尸体移植受者之间的患者和移植存活率差异显著(P小于0.001)。在存活至第二个十年的100例患者中,移植后15年时51%存活,41%移植肾功能良好。对于存活10年的HLA相同的同胞供者、配型不合的亲属供者移植受者和尸体供者移植受者,15年时分别有47%、57%和43%存活,分别有31%、45%和43%移植肾功能良好。对于存活至第二个十年的移植受者,此后患者和首次移植存活率在供者来源方面无统计学差异。23例患者在移植后的第二个十年死亡,其中10例死于心血管疾病。25例患者在第二个十年移植肾功能丧失,其中19例因移植肾功能良好时死亡。关于糖尿病并发症,糖尿病肾病复发很常见,但仅2例患者单纯因此原因移植肾功能丧失。在21例患者(42只眼)接受前瞻性随访10年中,26%的眼视力下降,64%稳定,10%改善。神经生理学测试结果表明,仅对肾移植受者而言,尿毒症的纠正并不能阻止糖尿病神经病变的进展。即使不使用环孢素,近三分之二的HLA相同肾移植受者、超过四分之一的配型不合的亲属供者移植受者和超过五分之一的尸体移植受者寿命延长超过10年。