Murnane J G, Brennan R B, Healy M G, Fenton O
J Environ Qual. 2015 Sep;44(5):1674-83. doi: 10.2134/jeq2014.07.0319.
Diffuse pollutant losses containing phosphorus (P), nitrogen (N), and suspended solids (SS) can occur when agricultural wastes are applied to soil. This study aimed to mitigate P, N, and SS losses in runoff from grassed soils, onto which three types of agricultural wastes (dairy slurry, pig slurry, and dairy-soiled water [DSW]), were applied by combining amendments of either zeolite and polyaluminum chloride (PAC) with dairy and pig slurries or zeolite and alum with DSW. Four treatments were investigated in rainfall simulation studies: (i) control soil, (ii) agricultural wastes, (iii) dairy and pig slurries amended with PAC and DSW amended with alum, and (iv) dairy and pig slurries amended with zeolite and PAC and DSW amended with zeolite and alum. Our data showed that combined amendments of zeolite and PAC applied to dairy and pig slurries reduced total P (TP) in runoff by 87 and 81%, respectively, compared with unamended slurries. A combined amendment of zeolite and alum applied to DSW reduced TP in runoff by 50% compared with unamended DSW. The corresponding reductions in total N (TN) were 56% for dairy slurry and 45% for both pig slurry and DSW. Use of combined amendments reduced SS in runoff by 73 and 44% for dairy and pig slurries and 25% for DSW compared with unamended controls, but these results were not significantly different from those using chemical amendments only. The findings of this study are that combined amendments of zeolite and either PAC or alum reduce TP and TN losses in runoff to a greater extent than the use of single PAC or alum amendments and are most effective when used with dairy slurry and pig slurry but less effective when used with DSW.
当将农业废弃物施用于土壤时,可能会出现含有磷(P)、氮(N)和悬浮固体(SS)的扩散性污染物损失。本研究旨在通过将沸石与聚合氯化铝(PAC)或沸石与明矾分别与乳牛粪浆和猪粪浆或与奶牛污水(DSW)混合进行改良,来减轻草地土壤径流中P、N和SS的损失。在降雨模拟研究中调查了四种处理方式:(i)对照土壤,(ii)农业废弃物,(iii)用PAC改良的乳牛粪浆和猪粪浆以及用明矾改良的DSW,(iv)用沸石和PAC改良的乳牛粪浆和猪粪浆以及用沸石和明矾改良的DSW。我们的数据表明,与未改良的粪浆相比,将沸石和PAC联合用于乳牛粪浆和猪粪浆时,径流中的总磷(TP)分别减少了87%和81%。将沸石和明矾联合用于DSW时,与未改良的DSW相比,径流中的TP减少了50%。乳牛粪浆中总氮(TN)的相应减少量为56%,猪粪浆和DSW均为45%。与未改良的对照相比,联合改良剂使乳牛粪浆和猪粪浆径流中的SS减少了73%和44%,使DSW径流中的SS减少了25%,但这些结果与仅使用化学改良剂的结果没有显著差异。本研究的结果是,沸石与PAC或明矾的联合改良剂比单独使用PAC或明矾改良剂能更大程度地减少径流中TP和TN的损失,并且与乳牛粪浆和猪粪浆一起使用时最有效,而与DSW一起使用时效果较差。