Erekson David M, Lambert Michael J, Eggett Dennis L
Department of Psychology.
Department of Statistics.
J Consult Clin Psychol. 2015 Dec;83(6):1097-107. doi: 10.1037/a0039774. Epub 2015 Oct 5.
The dose-response relationship in psychotherapy has been examined extensively, but few studies have included session frequency as a component of psychotherapy "dose." Studies that have examined session frequency have indicated that it may affect both the speed and the amount of recovery. No studies were found examining the clinical significance of this construct in a naturalistic setting, which is the aim of the current study.
Using an archival database of session-by-session Outcome Questionnaire 45 (OQ-45) measures over 17 years, change trajectories of 21,488 university counseling center clients (54.9% female, 85.0% White, mean age = 22.5) were examined using multilevel modeling, including session frequency at the occasion level. Of these clients, subgroups that attended therapy approximately weekly or fortnightly were compared to each other for differences in speed of recovery (using multilevel Cox regression) and clinically significant change (using multilevel logistic regression).
Results indicated that more frequent therapy was associated with steeper recovery curves (Cohen's f2 = 0.07; an effect size between small and medium). When comparing weekly and fortnightly groups, clinically significant gains were achieved faster for those attending weekly sessions; however, few significant differences were found between groups in total amount of change in therapy.
Findings replicated previous session frequency literature and supported a clinically significant effect, where higher session frequency resulted in faster recovery. Session frequency appears to be an impactful component in delivering more efficient psychotherapy, and it is important to consider in individual treatment planning, institutional policy, and future research.
心理治疗中的剂量反应关系已得到广泛研究,但很少有研究将治疗频率作为心理治疗“剂量”的一个组成部分。已研究治疗频率的研究表明,它可能会影响康复的速度和程度。未发现有研究在自然主义环境中检验这一构念的临床意义,而这正是本研究的目的。
利用一个17年期间逐次治疗的结果问卷45(OQ - 45)测量的存档数据库,使用多层次模型对21488名大学咨询中心来访者(54.9%为女性,85.0%为白人,平均年龄 = 22.5岁)的变化轨迹进行了研究,其中包括在每次治疗时的治疗频率。在这些来访者中,对大约每周或每两周接受一次治疗的亚组在康复速度(使用多层次Cox回归)和临床显著变化(使用多层次逻辑回归)方面进行相互比较。
结果表明,更频繁的治疗与更陡峭的康复曲线相关(科恩f2 = 0.07;效应大小介于小和中之间)。在比较每周和每两周治疗一次的组时,每周接受治疗的人在临床上显著改善的实现速度更快;然而,两组在治疗总变化量方面几乎没有发现显著差异。
研究结果重复了先前关于治疗频率的文献,并支持了一个具有临床意义的效应,即更高的治疗频率导致更快的康复。治疗频率似乎是提供更有效心理治疗的一个有影响力的组成部分,在个体治疗计划、机构政策和未来研究中加以考虑很重要。