Sager M A, Easterling D V, Kindig D A, Anderson O W
Department of Internal Medicine, Dean Medical Center, Madison, Wis 53715.
N Engl J Med. 1989 Feb 16;320(7):433-9. doi: 10.1056/NEJM198902163200705.
We reviewed age-specific national mortality data for the years 1981 through 1985 to evaluate changes in the location of death among the nation's elderly after implementation of Medicare's prospective payment system (PPS). Although it was unchanged in 1981 and 1982, the percentage of deaths occurring in the nation's nursing homes increased from 18.9 percent in 1982 to 21.5 percent in 1985. The increases in nursing home deaths were greatest between 1983 and 1984, when 33 states showed larger-than-expected increases when compared with a base period before implementation of PPS. These changes were accompanied by a decline in the percentage of deaths that occurred in hospitals. These changes in the location of death were most pronounced in the Midwest, South, and West; they were very small in the Northeast and in states not affected by the PPS. Furthermore, the states with high population enrollments in health maintenance organizations and with large declines in the mean hospital length of stay in 1984 showed the greatest shifts in the location of death. We conclude that Medicare's PPS resulted in the increased transfer of terminally ill patients from hospitals to nursing homes. Further study is required to determine whether such transfer is medically appropriate.
我们回顾了1981年至1985年特定年龄段的全国死亡率数据,以评估医疗保险预期支付系统(PPS)实施后美国老年人死亡地点的变化。尽管1981年和1982年没有变化,但美国养老院死亡人数的百分比从1982年的18.9%增至1985年的21.5%。养老院死亡人数的增加在1983年至1984年期间最为显著,与PPS实施前的基期相比,33个州的增长幅度超过预期。这些变化伴随着医院死亡人数百分比的下降。死亡地点的这些变化在中西部、南部和西部最为明显;在东北部以及未受PPS影响的州则非常小。此外,1984年健康维护组织参保人数众多且平均住院天数大幅下降的州,死亡地点的变化最为显著。我们得出结论,医疗保险的PPS导致了绝症患者从医院向养老院的转移增加。需要进一步研究以确定这种转移在医学上是否合适。