Gifford Elizabeth J, Sloan Frank A, Eldred Lindsey M, Evans Kelly E
Center for Child and Family Policy.
Department of Economics.
Am J Orthopsychiatry. 2015 Sep;85(5):452-68. doi: 10.1037/ort0000087.
This study examined the intergenerational effects of parental conviction of a substance-related charge on children's academic performance and, conditional on a conviction, whether completion of an adult drug treatment court (DTC) program was associated with improved school performance. State administrative data from North Carolina courts, birth records, and school records were linked for 2005-2012. Math and reading end-of-grade test scores and absenteeism were examined for 5 groups of children, those with parents who: were not convicted on any criminal charge, were convicted on a substance-related charge and not referred by a court to a DTC, were referred to a DTC but did not enroll, enrolled in a DTC but did not complete, and completed a DTC program. Accounting for demographic and socioeconomic factors, the school performance of children whose parents were convicted of a substance-related offense was worse than that of children whose parents were not convicted on any charge. These differences were statistically significant but substantially reduced after controlling for socioeconomic characteristics; for example, mother's educational attainment. We found no evidence that parent participation in an adult DTC program led to improved school performance of their children. While the children of convicted parents fared worse on average, much--but not all--of this difference was attributed to socioeconomic factors, with the result that parental conviction remained a risk factor for poorer school performance. Even though adult DTCs have been shown to have other benefits, we could detect no intergenerational benefit in improved school performance of their children.
本研究考察了父母因涉毒指控被定罪对子女学业成绩的代际影响,以及在父母被定罪的条件下,完成成人戒毒治疗法庭(DTC)项目是否与学业成绩改善相关。我们将北卡罗来纳州法院的州行政数据、出生记录和学校记录进行了关联,数据涵盖2005年至2012年。我们考察了五组儿童的数学和阅读年级末测试成绩以及缺勤情况,这五组儿童的父母分别是:未被任何刑事指控定罪的;因涉毒指控被定罪且未被法院转介至DTC的;被转介至DTC但未登记入学的;登记入学但未完成DTC项目的;以及完成了DTC项目的。在考虑人口统计学和社会经济因素后,父母因涉毒犯罪被定罪的儿童的学业表现比父母未被任何指控定罪的儿童更差。这些差异具有统计学意义,但在控制了社会经济特征(例如母亲的教育程度)后大幅减小。我们没有发现证据表明父母参与成人DTC项目会使其子女的学业表现得到改善。虽然被定罪父母的子女平均表现更差,但这种差异大部分(但并非全部)可归因于社会经济因素,结果是父母被定罪仍然是学业表现较差的一个风险因素。尽管成人DTC已被证明有其他益处,但我们未能发现其对子女学业表现改善有代际益处。