Landers J G, Esch Tobias
Chania, Crete, Greece.
Division of Integrative Health Promotion, Coburg University of Applied Sciences, Coburg, Germany; Institute for General Medicine, University Hospital, University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany; Neuroscience Research Institute, State University of New York, College at Old Westbury, New York, USA.
Med Hypotheses. 2015 Dec;85(6):905-9. doi: 10.1016/j.mehy.2015.09.012. Epub 2015 Sep 26.
Elite Spanish professional soccer players surprisingly showed a preponderance of an allele coding for nitric oxide synthase (NOS) that resulted in lower nitric oxide (NO) compared with Spanish endurance and power athletes and sedentary men. The present paper attempts a speculative explanation. Soccer is an "externally-paced" (EP) sport and team work dependent, requiring "executive function skills". We accept that time interval estimation skill is, in part, also an executive skill. Dopamine (DA) is prominent among the neurotransmitters with a role in such skills. Polymorphisms affecting dopamine (especially DRD2/ANKK1-Taq1a which leads to lower density of dopamine D2 receptors in the striatum, leading to increased striatal dopamine synthesis) and COMT val 158 met (which prolongs the action of dopamine in the cortex) feature both in the time interval estimation and the executive skills literatures. Our paper may be a pioneering attempt to stimulate empirical efforts to show how genotypes among soccer players may be connected via neurotransmitters to certain cognitive abilities that predict sporting success, perhaps also in some other externally-paced team sports. Graphing DA levels against time interval estimation accuracy and also against certain executive skills reveals an inverted-U relationship. A pathway from DA, via endogenous morphine and mu3 receptors on endothelia, to the generation of NO in tiny quantities has been demonstrated. Exercise up-regulates DA and this pathway. With somewhat excessive exercise, negative feedback from NO down-regulates DA, hypothetically keeping it near the peak of the inverted-U. Other research, not yet done on higher animals or humans, shows NO "fine-tuning" movement. We speculate that Caucasian men, playing soccer recreationally, would exemplify the above pattern and their nitric oxide synthase (NOS) would reflect the norm of their community, whereas professional players of soccer and perhaps other EP sports, with DA boosted by very frequent and intense practice and extra stress from public scrutiny, would potentially have their negative feedback system overwhelmed, were it not that many of them carry the C allele of the NOS3-786T/C polymorphism. Then, even very high DA would not result in so much NO as to shut the system down. We add some evolutionary speculations.
令人惊讶的是,西班牙职业足球精英运动员中编码一氧化氮合酶(NOS)的一种等位基因占优势,与西班牙耐力和力量型运动员以及久坐不动的男性相比,这导致一氧化氮(NO)水平较低。本文尝试给出一种推测性解释。足球是一项“外部节奏型”(EP)运动且依赖团队合作,需要“执行功能技能”。我们承认时间间隔估计技能在一定程度上也是一种执行技能。多巴胺(DA)在参与此类技能的神经递质中很突出。影响多巴胺的多态性(特别是DRD2/ANKK1 - Taq1a,它会导致纹状体中多巴胺D2受体密度降低,从而导致纹状体多巴胺合成增加)以及COMT val 158 met(它会延长多巴胺在皮质中的作用时间)在时间间隔估计和执行技能的文献中都有提及。我们的论文可能是一次开创性尝试,旨在激发实证研究,以揭示足球运动员的基因类型如何通过神经递质与某些预测运动成功的认知能力相联系,或许在其他一些外部节奏型团队运动中也是如此。将多巴胺水平与时间间隔估计准确性以及某些执行技能进行绘图,会呈现出一种倒U形关系。已经证实存在一条从多巴胺,经内源性吗啡和内皮细胞上的μ3受体,到产生少量一氧化氮的途径。运动可上调多巴胺及此途径。在运动略显过度时,一氧化氮的负反馈会下调多巴胺,据推测会使其保持在倒U形曲线的峰值附近。尚未在高等动物或人类身上进行的其他研究表明,一氧化氮对运动有“微调”作用。我们推测,从事休闲足球运动的白人男性会体现上述模式,他们的一氧化氮合酶(NOS)会反映其群体的常态,而足球以及或许其他EP运动的职业运动员,由于频繁且高强度的训练以及公众审视带来的额外压力,多巴胺水平升高,若不是他们中的许多人携带NOS3 - 786T/C多态性的C等位基因,其负反馈系统可能会不堪重负。那样的话,即使多巴胺水平非常高,也不会产生过多一氧化氮而使系统关闭。我们还添加了一些进化方面的推测。