Maeda Keisuke, Koga Takayuki, Akagi Junji
Department of Nutrition and Dysphagia Rehabilitation, Tamana Regional Health Medical Center, 2172 Tamana, Tamana City 865-0005, Kumamoto Prefecture, Japan; Division of Swallowing and Nutritional Therapy, Tamana Regional Health Medical Center, 2172 Tamana, Tamana City 865-0005, Kumamoto Prefecture, Japan.
Division of Swallowing and Nutritional Therapy, Tamana Regional Health Medical Center, 2172 Tamana, Tamana City 865-0005, Kumamoto Prefecture, Japan.
Clin Nutr. 2016 Oct;35(5):1147-52. doi: 10.1016/j.clnu.2015.09.011. Epub 2015 Oct 9.
BACKGROUND & AIMS: Patients with aspiration pneumonia (AP) may experience swallowing function declines during treatment, necessitating artificial feeding methods. Proper AP treatment contributes to maintaining activities of daily living. The aim was to assess the effect of tentative nil per os (NPO) status on the recovery of AP patients and declines in their swallowing abilities.
In this retrospective cohort study, 331 patients with AP having oral food intake in premorbid status were included after exclusions for reasons such as vomiting or respiratory insufficiency. We divided subjects into 2 groups: an early oral intake (EOI) group and a tentative NPO group according to the directions by the attending doctors at admission. We created a population model related to groupings from all subjects, which was a homoscedastic model without statistical differences by the inverse probability of treatment weighted (IPTW) method and compared outcomes between the groups.
In the IPTW model, tentative NPO status resulted in poorer nutritional intake every day for 1 week from the date of admission (p < 0.05), a significantly longer treatment duration (50% treatment length: NPO group, 13 days [95% confidence interval (CI), 12.04-13.96] and EOI group, 8 days [95% CI, 7.69-8.31 [log-rank test, p < 0.001]) and greater decline in swallowing ability over the course of treatment (p < 0.001).
Tentative NPO status with AP at hospital admission resulted in adverse effects on patients, including prolonged treatment duration and declines in swallowing ability. Avoiding unnecessary NPO might be another method to treat AP and contribute to the patient's outcomes in addition to medication administration.
吸入性肺炎(AP)患者在治疗期间可能会出现吞咽功能下降,需要采用人工喂养方法。恰当的AP治疗有助于维持日常生活活动能力。本研究旨在评估试验性禁食状态对AP患者康复及吞咽能力下降的影响。
在这项回顾性队列研究中,排除呕吐或呼吸功能不全等原因后,纳入331例病前有经口进食能力的AP患者。根据入院时主治医生的指示,将受试者分为两组:早期经口进食(EOI)组和试验性禁食组。我们通过治疗加权逆概率(IPTW)方法创建了一个与所有受试者分组相关的总体模型,该模型为同方差模型,无统计学差异,并比较了两组的结果。
在IPTW模型中,试验性禁食状态导致从入院日期起1周内每日营养摄入量较差(p<0.05),治疗持续时间显著延长(治疗时长的50%:禁食组为13天[95%置信区间(CI),12.04 - 13.96],EOI组为8天[95%CI,7.69 - 8.31][对数秩检验,p<0.001]),且治疗过程中吞咽能力下降幅度更大(p<0.001)。
入院时对AP患者采用试验性禁食状态会对患者产生不良影响,包括治疗持续时间延长和吞咽能力下降。除药物治疗外,避免不必要的禁食可能是治疗AP的另一种方法,并有助于改善患者预后。