Sun Xiao, Guo Liping, Shang Hongcai, Ren Ming, Wang Yue, Huo Da, Lei Xiang, Wang Hui, Zhai Jingbo
Tianjin University of TCM, 9 ShuangfengStreet, Nankai District, Tianjin, 300193, China.
Baokang Hospital of Tianjin University of TCM, Tianjin, China.
Trials. 2015 Nov 3;16:496. doi: 10.1186/s13063-015-0990-9.
At present, diabetes is a chronic disease of great cost and heavy burdens. The International Diabetes Federation has repeatedly warned that by 2025, the global number of diabetics would rise to 333 million from 194 million in 2003. Although the occurrence of diabetes in developing countries is lower, China has a large population, so that the number of cases is increased. At the same time, more people have prediabetes, a growing health concern where a large percentage of the patients develop full type 2 diabetes. In addition, the patients of diabetes easily incur complications such as blindness, kidney failure, and cardiovascular diseases that can seriously affect the patients' quality of life and cause great economic burdens to family and society. Therefore, effective interventions for prediabetes are needed to prevent or delay the occurrence and development of diabetes.
A randomized controlled trial that was assessed with pharmacoeconomic methods was undertaken in this study. The study term was 24 months (12 months for the intervention and 12 months for follow up). Four hundred participants, recruited from four cities in China: Beijing, Tianjin, Xian, and Naning, were randomized to the treatment group (JQJT tablets) and the control group (placebo). Participants included in this study had been diagnosed with prediabetes according to the criteria for western medicine and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). The end-point effectiveness indexes included the incidence of diabetes and the reversion rate. The drug costs and lifestyle intervention costs were included in the total costs. The study used the cost-effectiveness analysis to discuss the economic advantage of the JQJT tablets.
The outcomes of the study contained 2 sections,namely clinical outcomes and cost-effectiveness analysis outcomes. The clinical outcomes: the treatment group and control group had no significant statistical difference P> 0.05) on the baseline of situation; Jinqi Jiangtang tablet effectively reduced the incidence of diabetes mellitus and enhanced reversion rate. compared with the control group (p< 0.05); the scores of SF-36 of two groups had no significant difference P> 0.05); finally the compliance of participants between the two groups had no significant difference. The cost-effectiveness analysis outcomes:in the intervention period of 12 months,on the aspect of reversion rate, the treatment group had better economic advantage by using cost-effectiveness ratio and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio;on the aspect of the incidence of diabetes, the control group had better economic advantage by using cost-effectiveness ratio and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio; in the follow-up period of 24 months, on the aspect of reversion rate, the treatment group had better economic advantage by using cost-effectiveness ratio and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio, on the aspect of the incidence of diabetes, the control group had better economic advantage by using cost-effectivenes ratio and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio.At the same time, these outcomes remained the same by sensitivity analysis. Assuming that prices and resident incomes rose 5%, the sensitiveness analysis shows that the two group affected by the paremeters changed little.
The importance and effectiveness of lifestyle education and JinQi Jiangtang tablets was proven. In both the intervention period and follow-up, JinQi Jiangtang tablets combined with lifestyle education had a greater cost advantage effect than the lifestyle education alone on the reversion rate; the lifestyle education had a greater cost advantage effect than the JinQi Jiangtang tablets combined with lifestyle education on the incidence of diabetes.
Chinese Clinical Trials ChiCTR-TRC-09000401 ) , registered on 25 May 2009.
目前,糖尿病是一种成本高昂、负担沉重的慢性疾病。国际糖尿病联盟多次警告,到2025年,全球糖尿病患者人数将从2003年的1.94亿增至3.33亿。尽管发展中国家糖尿病发病率较低,但中国人口众多,致使病例数增加。同时,糖尿病前期患者增多,这一健康问题日益受到关注,因为很大比例的患者会发展为2型糖尿病。此外,糖尿病患者易引发失明、肾衰竭和心血管疾病等并发症,严重影响患者生活质量,给家庭和社会带来巨大经济负担。因此,需要对糖尿病前期进行有效干预,以预防或延缓糖尿病的发生和发展。
本研究采用随机对照试验,并运用药物经济学方法进行评估。研究周期为24个月(干预12个月,随访12个月)。从中国北京、天津、西安和南宁四个城市招募400名参与者,随机分为治疗组(金芪降糖片)和对照组(安慰剂)。本研究纳入的参与者已根据西医和中医标准被诊断为糖尿病前期。终点有效性指标包括糖尿病发病率和逆转率。总成本包括药物成本和生活方式干预成本。本研究采用成本效益分析来探讨金芪降糖片的经济优势。
研究结果包括两部分,即临床结果和成本效益分析结果。临床结果:治疗组和对照组在基线情况上无显著统计学差异(P>0.05);金芪降糖片有效降低了糖尿病发病率,提高了逆转率,与对照组相比差异有统计学意义(P<0.05);两组SF-36评分无显著差异(P>0.05);最后两组参与者的依从性无显著差异。成本效益分析结果:在12个月的干预期,在逆转率方面,治疗组采用成本效益比和增量成本效益比具有更好的经济优势;在糖尿病发病率方面,对照组采用成本效益比和增量成本效益比具有更好的经济优势;在24个月的随访期,在逆转率方面,治疗组采用成本效益比和增量成本效益比具有更好的经济优势,在糖尿病发病率方面,对照组采用成本效益比和增量成本效益比具有更好的经济优势。同时,敏感性分析显示这些结果保持不变。假设价格和居民收入上涨5%,敏感性分析表明两组受参数变化影响较小。
证明了生活方式教育和金芪降糖片的重要性和有效性。在干预期和随访期,金芪降糖片联合生活方式教育在逆转率方面比单纯生活方式教育具有更大的成本优势效应;在糖尿病发病率方面,生活方式教育比金芪降糖片联合生活方式教育具有更大的成本优势效应。
中国临床试验(ChiCTR-TRC-09000401),于2009年5月25日注册。