Song Hummy, Ryan Molly, Tendulkar Shalini, Fisher Josephine, Martin Julia, Peters Antoinette S, Frolkis Joseph P, Rosenthal Meredith B, Chien Alyna T, Singer Sara J
Hummy Song, MPP, is PhD Candidate, PhD Program in Health Policy, Harvard University, Boston, Massachusetts. E-mail:
Health Care Manage Rev. 2017 Jan/Mar;42(1):28-41. doi: 10.1097/HMR.0000000000000091.
Team-based care is essential for delivering high-quality, comprehensive, and coordinated care. Despite considerable research about the effects of team-based care on patient outcomes, few studies have examined how team dynamics relate to provider outcomes.
The aim of this study was to examine relationships among team dynamics, primary care provider (PCP) clinical work satisfaction, and patient care coordination between PCPs in 18 Harvard-affiliated primary care practices participating in Harvard's Academic Innovations Collaborative.
First, we administered a cross-sectional survey to all 548 PCPs (267 attending clinicians, 281 resident physicians) working at participating practices; 65% responded. We assessed the relationship of team dynamics with PCPs' clinical work satisfaction and perception of patient care coordination between PCPs, respectively, and the potential mediating effect of patient care coordination on the relationship between team dynamics and work satisfaction. In addition, we embedded a qualitative evaluation within the quantitative evaluation to achieve a convergent mixed methods design to help us better understand our findings and illuminate relationships among key variables.
Better team dynamics were positively associated with clinical work satisfaction and quality of patient care coordination between PCPs. Coordination partially mediated the relationship between team dynamics and satisfaction for attending clinicians, suggesting that higher satisfaction depends, in part, on better teamwork, yielding more coordinated patient care. We found no mediating effects for resident physicians. Qualitative results suggest that sources of satisfaction from positive team dynamics for PCPs may be most relevant to attending clinicians.
Improving primary care team dynamics could improve clinical work satisfaction among PCPs and patient care coordination between PCPs. In addition to improving outcomes that directly concern health care providers, efforts to improve aspects of team dynamics may also help resolve critical challenges in workforce planning in primary care.
团队协作式护理对于提供高质量、全面且协调的护理至关重要。尽管关于团队协作式护理对患者治疗效果影响的研究颇多,但很少有研究探讨团队动态与医护人员治疗效果之间的关系。
本研究旨在探讨参与哈佛学术创新合作项目的18家哈佛附属初级护理机构中,团队动态、初级护理提供者(PCP)临床工作满意度以及PCP之间患者护理协调情况之间的关系。
首先,我们对参与机构工作的所有548名PCP(267名主治医生、281名住院医生)进行了横断面调查;65%的人做出了回应。我们分别评估了团队动态与PCP临床工作满意度以及PCP之间患者护理协调认知的关系,以及患者护理协调对团队动态与工作满意度关系的潜在中介作用。此外,我们在定量评估中嵌入了定性评估,以实现收敛性混合方法设计,帮助我们更好地理解研究结果,并阐明关键变量之间的关系。
更好的团队动态与临床工作满意度以及PCP之间患者护理协调质量呈正相关。协调在一定程度上介导了团队动态与主治医生满意度之间的关系,这表明更高的满意度部分取决于更好的团队合作,从而产生更协调的患者护理。我们发现住院医生不存在中介效应。定性结果表明,PCP从积极团队动态中获得的满意度来源可能与主治医生最为相关。
改善初级护理团队动态可以提高PCP的临床工作满意度以及PCP之间的患者护理协调水平。除了改善直接关乎医疗服务提供者的治疗效果外,改善团队动态方面的努力还可能有助于解决初级护理劳动力规划中的关键挑战。