Gocotano Allison E, Dico Fidelita D, Calungsod Neil R, Hall Julie L, Counahan Megan L
World Health Organization Representative Office for the Philippines, Department of Health Compound, Sta Cruz, 1003 Manila, Philippines .
Department of Health Regional Office VIII, Tacloban, Philippines .
Bull World Health Organ. 2015 Nov 1;93(11):810-4. doi: 10.2471/BLT.15.158089. Epub 2015 Sep 22.
The visit of Pope Francis to the Philippines in January 2015 coincided with a tropical storm. For security reasons, the only road in and out of the area was closed 14.5 hours before the Pope's arrival. This meant that people had to wait for many hours with little shelter at the site. Medical teams in the field reported high numbers of people with cold stress during the mass gathering.
To review the event from a public health perspective, we examined the consultations made by medical teams in the field and interviewed key stakeholders, focusing on cold stress as a public health risk.
The key reason for the Pope's visit to Palo and Tacloban was the devastation caused in these cities by typhoon Haiyan in 2013. We estimated that the visit attracted 300 000 people. The medical teams were advised to consider cold stress risks two days before the event but no other measures were taken.
Of the 1051 people seeking medical care, 231 people were experiencing symptoms of cold stress. People with cold stress ranged from 2 to 89 years of age and were more likely to be female than male, 173 (75%) versus 57 (25%).
Planning for mass gatherings should consider a wide range of public health risks, including cold stress. Improved data collection from the field is necessary to maximize the benefits of post-event evaluations and improve public health preparedness. Security measures to ensure the safety of key figures must be balanced with public health risks.
2015年1月教皇方济各访问菲律宾时恰逢一场热带风暴。出于安全考虑,进出该地区的唯一道路在教皇抵达前14.5小时关闭。这意味着人们不得不在现场等待数小时,而且几乎没有遮蔽处。现场医疗团队报告称,在群众集会期间,有大量人员出现冷应激症状。
为从公共卫生角度审视这一事件,我们查阅了现场医疗团队的会诊记录,并采访了关键利益相关者,重点关注冷应激这一公共卫生风险。
教皇访问帕洛和塔克洛班的主要原因是2013年台风海燕给这些城市造成的破坏。我们估计此次访问吸引了30万人。在活动前两天,医疗团队就被建议考虑冷应激风险,但未采取其他措施。
在1051名寻求医疗护理的人员中,有231人出现冷应激症状。出现冷应激症状的人员年龄在2岁至89岁之间,女性比男性更易出现,分别为173人(75%)和57人(25%)。
大规模集会的规划应考虑包括冷应激在内的广泛公共卫生风险。有必要改进现场数据收集,以最大限度地提高事后评估的效益并改善公共卫生防范能力。确保关键人物安全的安保措施必须与公共卫生风险相平衡。